IT WAS NOT a pretty sight: thousands of militant Polish workers giving enthuslastic applause to Margaret Thatcher in Gdansk. How could they be so wrong?
Of course, the television coverage was selective. It did not high- light the leaflets distributed by left wing Solidarnose activists oppos- ing the Thatcher visit and Lech Walesa for inviting her. If did not headline the Solidarnosc steering committee statement degouncing the sacking of GCHQ trade unionists. And it downplayed the extent to which Polish militants were simply using the Thatcher visit as a pretext for their own mobilisation, especially since the Lenin shipyard faces closure. But the applanse was definitely there, and represents a real problem.
We must remember that Solldarnose exists- despite brutal repres- sion - because in Poland the official trade unions are simply organs of management and state control over the workers. More than forty years of a stalinist pollce state pumping out 'communist' propagan- da and obligatory bureaucratic "marxism', together with vicious repression of independent political currents, have totally disorien- tated many sections of Polish workers.
Their experience of life in the 'socialist camp' - of queues, shortages and bureaucratic privilege and corruption upheld by tanks and baton charges - Is not one which engenders tender affection. Polish workers' well-founded mistrust of all official pronouncements and their lack of independent information leaves them vulnerable to the politics of the crude populist right like Thatcher. The confusion is compounded by the role of the catholic church, which bas been carcfully nurtured by the Polish burcaucracy as a useful diversion from class struggle.
There is no basis for the British left to look scornfully on the Polish events. The soft line on stalinism which led to the timid refusal of many would-be socialists to support the Solidarnose struggles in 1980-81, or mobilise to oppose General Jaruzelski's military crack- down, created the bizarre and baffling spectacle of Tony Benn and Arthur Scargill opposing strikers while Thatcher and Reagan shouted hypocritical support: how should we expect Polish workers to understand that?
Ifany of these same timid socialists now daim they were right all along, and that the welcome for Thatcher is 'proof" that Solidarnose Is nothing but a counter-revolutionary church conspiracy, they should ask themselves the difficult question: why did Jaruzelski in- vite her to Poland in the first place? Why is it Jaruzelski who most vocally praises Thatcher's 'free market" approach, and his industry minister who praises her hard line against the miners' strike?
The fact Is that despite its nationalised economy, far from having developed as a 'socialist' state. Poland is reaping the bitter harvest of decades of bureaucratic misrule. The Warsaw bureaucracy, like those In most of eastern Europe, Is composed of 'communists" who have never led or supported a revolution, ruling countries where the working class has never (as it did in the 1917 Russian Revolution) held power in its own hands.
The expropriation of the old cast European capitalists in the years after 1944 was carried out from above by a powerful, bureaucratised state machine, under the watchful eyes and guns of Stalin's Red Army. Though the direct subordination to the Kremlin has gradual- ly been relaxed, and certain rivalries and differentiations have oc- curred, the political base of the bureaucracy in each country remains the suppression of any independent movement of the working class; this means steadfast opposition to any genuine workers' control.
Instead, the bureaucracy itself has been managing the creaking
SOCIALISTOUTLOOKno11December1988/January1989
and increasingly inefficient economies, following the traditional stalinist conception of seeking to build 'socialism' in a single country. The result has been not a defence but an undermining of the pretence of a planned economy; the east European countries have plunged ever deeper into debt with imperialist bankers, offering ever-greater concessions to encourage major capitalist firms to set up new busi nesses there - with profits guaranteed by the 'workers" state. Though the bureaucrats understand that their power and privilege rest on their control of a nationalised economy, and would be eliminated were capitalism to be restored, they are incapable of