Austin Rover, British Aerospace).
There are battles in the NHS: hattles by council tenants against compulsory transfer to private landlords, and the perennial fight of workers against victimisations of militants. Women face even more pressure to choose hetween low paid, low status part time jobs or staying at home on poverty level benefits caring for children or handicapped, sick or elderly rela- tives.
The Solidarity Network cannot promise to win on all of these is- sues: but it can begin to support those who are fighting, and make the links between the campaigns.
For affiliation, copies of the bulletin or more details of local contacts, write to the Secretary. Andrea Campbell. 6. Cherisey House, Arnold Circus. London E2
Andrea Campbell
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 11 Dec
GCHQ - TUC bottles out
RECENT developments around the fight to defend the jobs of trade union members at GCHQ contrast the timidity of the TUC leadership and the willingness of union members to take action.
Thousands of trade union mem- hers took strike action on Novem- ber 7th, by no means all of them civil servants, and demonstrations and rallies look place in many major towns, often organised inde- pendently of the TUC
For its part, the TUC called on union members to do no more on "GCHQ Day" than tum up in their hreaks to the rallies. Many TUC unions circulated nothing more than this appeal, though the civil service unions balloted their mem- hers and NALGO local govern- ment conference voled for a one- day strike.
Ever since the ban on union membership was announced in January 1984 (to be enforced from March) the TUC and civil service union leaderships have avoided the scale of fight needed to force the government to back down, despite fine speeches about democratic rights. They have preferred to become enmeshed in
appeals to British and European courts and the International Labour Organisation.
In choosing to make their main focuscounteringthe government's arguments in courtrooms rather than mobilising for action, the TUC and CCSU (Council of Civil Service Unions) have conceded large parts of the Tories argument.
They have quoted Tory state- ments on how industrial action by civil servants never disrupted operations at GCHQ as proof of how unnecessary the han is and have argued that there is no con- tradiction between TU member- ship and 'defence of the national interest", that trade unionists are as patriotic as the ruling class (or more so).
Despite winning the support of all opposition parties to a commil- ment to restore trade union nights at GCHQ. all of this has (predict- ably) not prevented the govem- ment moving ahead with its policy, sacking union members, or union membership dwindling to a small hard core.
If union membership means anything, then ultimately it means taking industrial action, and if such action is to achieve anything it has
to he effective and hit the employers. The right to union membership without the right to take effective action is only half a right.
Similarly, acceptance of a com- mon national interest concedes the argument to the Tories. If there in such a common interest then it makes sense for the elected government of the day" to decide what it is at any one time. Of course, challenging the idea of such a common interest also means questioning the need for spy-centres like GCHQ Chelten- ham and arguing for alterative employment.
TUC and CCSU pussyfooting has considerably weakened the fight to defend trade union rights, but it doesn't mean the fight is lost. The response to even the limited call on November 7th shows the possibilities. Union activists have to step up support for the further actions called by the CCSU and TUC, but also demand they go beyond their present policy to call- ing all-out action, the only way to stop the Tories taking away more and more of our democratic rights.
Pete Firmin
Strange line-up in Austin Rover
pay sell-out
AUSTIN Rover's 23,000 hourly paid workers have voted by a two to one majority to accept a two-year deal recently offered by manage- ment and promoted by a curious alliance of the Com- munist Party and the hard-line right wing.
The negotiations and the agreement at the end of them were extraordinary. The JNC were taken to a plush residential conference centre for three days. Management put E500 behind the bar for their drinks in the evening.
At the end of the negotiations, acceptance of the offer was proposed by the Electricians' (BETPU) representative, and supported by Jack Adams, the TOWU national officer, a mem- ber of the Communist Party. He was backed on this by the
Longhridge delegation, who are strongly influenced by Adams.
More surprising still was the spectacle of the deal being op- posed by the regular right wing, including every representative from Cowley, among them Ivor Braggins, convenor of the Cowley assembly plant, who isa right wing opponent of General Secretary Ron Todd on the TGWU executive.
In selling the deal to the mem- bership, both the management and those (including the Morning Star) who supported it exag- gerated the size of the offer by in- cluding the shift allowances in their figures.
The settlement tepresents a four percent increase on basic rates plus sizabic increases in shift allowances. In cash tenns it is worth E7.50 for the first year
and 28.50 the next: it falls far l short of the unions" claim, sub- mitted three months ago, for an eight percent (£15) per woek in- crease in a one-year deal.
The wording on the ballot paper held out no possibility of further negotiations if the offer were rejected, saying that: "The only alternative is to take in- dustrial action, and therefore if the deal is not accepted there will be an immediate ballot for strike action*.
However wages were not the only thing at stake in this pay review. Austin Rover stands on the brink of massive redundan- cies and the threat of closure of its Cowley body and assembly com- plex. A successful campaign on the wage review could have radicalised the membership for action to defend jobs as well.
Alan Thornett
Page 3
PHOTO: Piers Cavendish/Reflex
PHOTO: Pier
Gillespie looks smug - before the Govan result
Govan by-election:
a warning to Kinnock
anour party in
land parto - • Govan. all the agne result her unl deepen the division strate which
2001
-36201
10l ..
developed since last year's general election.
Jim Sillar's victory, which the Scoltish National Party has hailed as a sea-change in Scottish
Politics, was indeed impressive, if sadly predictable, achievement for
Poli: sadiv
the nationanstr Overtuming a labour majority of 19.000, Sillars increased the SN' share of the vote to forty-eight percent. Labour's vote slumped from 24,000 at the general clection to just nver 11,000.
The SNP mounted a high profile campaign, flooding the constituency with activists. They emphasised opposition to the Poll Tax and support for a campaign of non-payment, while pouring scorn on the ineffectual conduct of Labour's feeble fifty' MPs.
By contrast, Lahour's cam- paign generated little enthusiasm. The candidate, Bob Gillespie's stance on the poll tax - personal non-payment, combined with a refusal to call on others to do Likewise - epitomised the timidity and incoherence of Labour's offi- cial position.
In response to the defcat, the party leader has called for an en- quiry into why Lahour lost. Scot tish organiser, Jimmy Allison has already ventured to suggest that the Govan electorate enquiry is un- likely to identify the real factors
it the
Page 4
de lav Labour s or netant. The problem
Jovan "
whelmingly working class
electorate failed to understand the
party's policies. Rather it is those
policies themselves - not least of
refusing to organise any serious
resistance to the poll tax - which
the have been tested and found want-
SURING
poll
and lound want-
ing.
Two months ago, the Scottish
Lahour party held a rocall con-
ference to decide the party's at-
titude to the poll lax. The con- ference
was organised
presumably by somcone with a
strung sense of irony - in Govan town hall. Atthe conference, in the face of strong opposition from the left, the party leadership reaf- finned the strategy of the "dented shield". Surrender to the Tories now; hope for a Labour govern- meat sooner or later.
It is little exaggeration to say that the Govan by-election was Jost two mooths agu in Govan town hall, and the explanations
which concentrate on the personal calibre of the candidates or the technical details of the campaign simply obscure as basic fact of Scottish political life. As the prospect of a Kinnock led Labour government in Westminster recedes into political make- believe, and in the absence of a serious fight, the SN's vision - of an independent Scotland within the EEC - will continue to gain ground. In this respect, the Govan by-election should stand both as a challenge and a warning to the Scotlish left.
Blesses
lan Gault
Thatcher's Britain
No right to
speak - or stay
silent!
WITH THE annesten a media ban on the e of republican view- removal or the histor silence. it is clear Thatcher govemment has be- come one of the most repres- sive this century.
cumstances - by saying: "the hest way to ensure there is no denial of
and the ic right to that the i has be- st reprer
justice is to make such practices
The media han has similarly
been implemented through the
wholly undemocratic structures of
the British state. Self-censorship
was already widespread in the media, with dovens of program-
mes on Ireland altered or withdrawn since the early 1970s. The ban itself in being described
official and legal'.
The
AWEETENS
Coming un the wake development. in recen total erosinn nt trada. the Dann on 1 bian and gar kill policien and the " black and Irish pran Amnestv Inremt.... British Justic past wears there for a bronu polin.
Al -
the bann on the "promotion" ofles bian and gay sexuality, shoot-to
*. :9/0s. ... describo-
by TV and radio newsreaders as applying to "Northern Irish or-
ganısatsons linked to terrorism: in fact the han is a broad political ecep aimed at clumping down on the growth of any public debate on
char
Irish issue.
defence of democratic rights.
The right to silence is an ancient
right than can be dated back to the
abolition of the Star Chamber in 1641. Under the star chamber, and
the European inquisitorial judicial systems, the accused were forced through the use of torture to in- criminate themselv-- The development of rules preventing those accused from heing cum- pelled to appear as witnesses in their own cases, and barring the prosecution from commenting ad versely on the exercise of this right - hecame basic elements of any system in which there is a presumption of innocence and the onus is on the prosecution to prove guilt.
Although the current proposals do not appear to affect the defendant's right not be a witness in court, the abolition of the pre- trial right to silence is in many ways more dangeroux. It is while in custody - often denied accessto lawyers, questioned for lengthy periods, denied sleep, isolated and vunerable-that prisoners are most exposed to pressure to make. con- fessions. The government has responded to the concer over the
Totlenham Three, Guildford Four,
and the Birmingham Six cases - all heavily based on talse 'confessions" under such cir-
d bac
the government's handling of the
Within weeks, those barined in cluded the late Miriam James of
illee nn Irelanc
programme about the Guildford Four, featuring Errol Smalley (one
prove.
• McA
BINKEV. S C0iu ane sinildfon D Smalysmm
of their relatives) and Sinn Fein
councillor Dodie McGuiness on
the closure of a Derry maternity
unit. Suppression of poblic sup- port for the IRA is thus a very small part of the ban's aim.
This will make official a double standard in electoral politics - in which different rights are acconded to voters, representatives and par-
ties according to whether they sup
port or oppose the government on
key issues. Today it is Ireland.
Tomorrow it may be extend to
those advocating defiance of the
Poll Tax, Section 28, or trade
'E ente
Kur issues
union laws.
The current attacks on civil
liherties will most certainly not be
the last: it is well known that fur-
ther measures on the cards include
enabling convections for IRA membership to be obtained solely
on the word of an RUC officer; and the introduction of an oath against violence for electoral candidates.
The widespread opposition to the measures is very positive. Despite its apparent strength, the government is taking a big risk
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 11 December 1988/January 1989