U D CE
THI LOSIN
British nurses: abandoned by union leaderships
British nurses need French lessons!
FRENCH nurses, inspired by the example of the British nurses' strikes earlier this year, are now showing British health workers how it should be done.
While Tory health secretary Kenneth Clarke was still giving unions the run-around on the fund- ing and implementation of last spring's pay award and regrading exercise, 240,000 French nurses were hitting the streets in a mas- sive one-day strike on September 29.
And as leaders of COHSE and NUPE were publicly snubbed and refused even a meeting with Clarke to discuss unresolved grad- ing issues - and the government insisted gradings would be unilaterally imposed on nursing staff - French nurses stepped up the pressure with a huge 100,000- strong national demonstration and a programme of rolling 24-hour strikes.
One obvious difference is that while the British nurses who have taken action are largely organised in unions (mostly the Confedera- tion of Health Service Employees (COHSE), with the National Union of Public Employees
Page 6
(NUPE) more reluctant to sanction strikes), only five per cent of French nurses are unionised. Their mushrooming strike movement has not therefore had to contend with indifference or outright sabotage from national union offi- cials, and has been led instead by an unofficial nurses coordinating committee including trotskyists from the Ligue Communiste Revolutionnaire.
This rank and file body began meeting in Paris to formulate pay demands last April, and was at first attended by 100 nurses from 22 hospitals. By mid-September it had grown to 500 nurses from 108 Paris hospitals and 12 in the provinces.
Such has been the success of this coordination in expressing the anger of nurses at their low wages and worsening conditions that they have even forced the reluctant bureaucrats of the Communist Party-dominaied CGT union con- federation into action, creating links with other groups of public sector workers pursuing their own pay demands against the Rocard government.
This patter - partly reflecting
the extremely low level of union organisation in France - is very different from events in Britain, where the January and February explosion of militancy has been ground down by months of inac- tion and indecision from national officials. The Tory government's shrewdly 'generous' pay award with its intricate regrading proposals has also bogged down many activists for months on end.
The result has been the irony of French nurses marching under the slogan 'British nurses beat Thatcher, we can beat Rocard', while British nurses themselves have in many areas run into stonewalling managers refusing to concede them the grading (and therefore the pay) to which they are entitled.
Kenneth Clarke's well-trum- peted concession of an extra £138m towards funding the nurses' pay award still leaves a gap of at least £60m, on top of shortfalls on other pay settlements in the NHS, and a widening gap caused by rising inflation. The Na- tional Association of Health Authorities has warned that 94 per centof health districts are planning
cutbacks to balance their books: this will make them even more stubborn in resisting union appeals over grading claims.
However, it now seems that COSHE's key base of psychiatric nurses are emerging on the scene, and may push the unions into a na- tional "work to grading' policy, beginning with some large Lon- don Hospitals.
Meanwhile, flummoxed by Clarke's tactics, union leaders have again handed the initiative back to the anti-strike Royal Col- lege of Nursing, making no call for industrial action (either strikes or "work to grading") to enforce the pay deal and prevent further at- tacks.
As a new winter of crisis ap- proaches, the lack of a rank and file movement remotely comparable to the French nurses' movement underlines the real problem - a resounding silence from national leaders and a feeling of local isola- tion. Socialists in health unions and elsewhere should be redou- bling their efforts to break this isolation and build support for a new round of struggle.
Harry Sloan
SOCIALIST JTLOOK no 10 November 1988