Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Labour Statement on Ireland: Writing off Withdrawal

· Socialist Outlook no. 10, November 1988 · pp 11-12 · 1,029 words

Ireland Labour Party

E A STAUR ES

Labour Party statement on

Ireland:

In September the Labour Party published a 32-page document outlining its democratic socialist programme' for achieving an end to 'violence, poverty and division' in Ireland. The document, complete with foreword by the Right Honourable Neil Kinnock MP, is the party's most important document on Ireland for a very long time - to judge, at least, by its length.

The Labour leadership's usual con- tributions on Ireland consist of attempts to outdo the government in its condem- nation of 'terrorist' violence or its con- gratulations to the SAS. Given this,

some people might interpret the publi- cation of the document as a great step forward for the withdrawal movement.

It is understandable that the left might feel a

sense of victory, in that the leadership has been forced to say something on Ireland other than its usual knee-jerk reactions to the latest "atrocity'. But it would be foolish and prema- ture to start popping champagne corks (or whatever it is that anti-imperialists do on these occasions) at this point.

designed to achieve 'the erosion of historically and culturally entrenched communal an- tagonisms to enable a united Ireland to function

harmoniously'.

Thus it gives the impression that the problem with Ireland is the obsession of its people with

British Troops in Dublin, 1917 history and with religion - a typi-

history and with religion - a typi- cally anti-Irish racist assumption.

The more detailed aspects of Labour's reform programme are not greatly different from what it promises the working classes of England, Scotland and Wales.

It will 'introduce measures designed to begin to reverse the extreme inequalities which have

Anglo-Irish Agreement — an agreement which has failed in every possible respect. In place of any recognition of this fact, we have a proposal to expand the scope and resources of the Agree- ment, the Inter-Governmental Conference and the secretariat which services it. There's noth-

The approach outlined in the document goes resulted from the market-based policies of the as follows. The Labour Party is a democratic Conservative Government' •For instance, it will party and therefore it will not make any chan- create a unit of the Northern Ireland Office to ges in the sovereignty of the six-counties co-ordinate state investment and economic as- without the consent of the majority. However, sistance. it is in favour in principle of a united Ireland

It will co-ordinate European and external in- since it recognises that* ...the national question, vestment and it will increase public spending on and hence the border, is central to the "troubles" housing and infrastructure. and that only the resolution of that question can

The document states that 'Much of Labour's bring peace'. Hence it will embark on a politi- longer-term economic strategy will be based on cal programme designed to win the consent of the strengthening of economic ties with the the loyalists to a united Ireland.

Republic'. Given the disastrous state of the 26

The loyalists will be given a veto on the ques- county economy, that is a statement more like- tion of sovereignty but they will not be given a ly to encourage nationalists to sign up with lan veto on policies designed to win 'consent'. . The Paisley than to encourage loyalists to consent to document's authors admit that they don't know the removal of the border! how they will measure 'consent' but they assure

On political reform: 'A Labour administra- us that a future Labour government will be able tion will promote the negotiation of an agreed to ascertain somehow that 'consent' was being system of devolved government including a given. power-sharing executive as envisaged in the

The two key words in the document are Anglo-Irish Agreement' 'However, if "political reform and harmonisation: reform of the north parties' (it doesn't specify which) don't agree a and harmonisation with the south. Its only structure for a devolved government, a Labour criticism of the Anglo-Irish Accord is that there government will continue with direct rule. Even is not enough reform and not enough har- if such a devolved government structure could monisation in it. Irish people everywhere will be agreed, the document warns that a Labour be delighted to hear that what the Labour Party government will continue to hang onto direct has in store for them is some weighted average control of any areas it sees fit. of the economic, legal, political, educational

The second half of this political programme and cultural institutions of the 6- and 26- coun- is designed to win consent - "harmonisation' ty statelets.

To carry out this programme, a Labour govern- • The reform part of the programme is ment would use the institutions set up by the

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 10 November 1988

ing like starting out on a sound footing!

Among the subjects due to be harmonised are the economy, social security provision, educa- tional provision, legal structures and last, but most certainly not least, security. To facilitate the latter, 'measures will have to be taken to rebuild public confidence in the respective police forces and other security services'. In particular, we can look forward to the eventual integration of the different agencies. Readers (and Robert Russell) will be forgiven if they were under the obviously mistaken impression that this is one bit of harmonisation which has already taken place.

So there we have it, the biggest document on Ireland the Labour Party has produced for many years - one page for every county in Ireland. Yet in almost every respect it is a waste of paper. It will not contribute one iota to Irish unity or to furthering the rights of Irish people to determine their own future. In fact, it explicitly rules out the one policy which might achieve that end - a commitment and a timetable to withdraw.

Perhaps this is all we can expect from a leadership which picks out as one of the three failures of successive British governments, the failure 'to steer Northern Ireland's people towards a just and democratic accommodation of their differences'.

If only that were the worst of it.

Jean Reilly

Page 9

F HER A R

Rocky road

for Kinnock

← British Aerospace: asset stripping · Labour Party Conference: Round-Up →

Something wrong on this page?