Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

'I was there': an eye-witness report

· Socialist Outlook no. 10, November 1988 · pp 18-22 · 4,019 words

Trotsky Marxism Latin America Stalinism

CHARLIE missed the first day of the Congress, when the discus

sion took place on the Transitional

Programme, but was present on

the second when the vote to found the Fourth International took

place. Three people, including two

of Deutcher's supporters from

Poland, out of 21 present voted against. They felt it was not an

auspicious time to found a new in-

ternational in a period of defeats

for the class.The previous three in- ternationals had been founded at

times of great working class strug

gle and upsurge, whereas in 1938 y world war was looming, the Left Op-

position was small and isolated

and the task facing revolutionaries , seemed a truly daunting one.

Charlie's view was, and remains so

today, that there was no alterna-

tive. The Second and Third Interna-

tionals were dead as far as the in-

ternational working class and revolutionary socialism were con-

cerned and it was therefore neces-

sary to take this step.

He was was twenty-four, and en- joyed meeting all those people who

had just been names to him, espe-

cially James P.Cannon. He had

been initiated in the trotskyist

movement through reading

Trotsky's articles in the Militant at

the time Cannon and Shackman

were the editors. He recalls

'Shackman was a remarkable

writer and personality, despite

what happenned to him after-

wards. He was fluent in French, al-

though they told be his French 1 grammer was atrocious, I didn't

notice, he chaired the meeting

translating from French to German, and so I was very impressed'.

Charlie attended the Congress

at the request of the South African

trotskyists with whom he had been

involved, although by this time he

had moved to England. He

reported back to meetings when he

returned to England and was

greeted enthusiastically.Then he

went on to spend six months work- I ing for the International in

France, turning duplicator hand-

les,before spending the war in Italy where he helped to found a sec-

tion.

Charlie is appalled when he looks back at the complete lack of security around the Con- gress.Everyone sat around in cafes talking, including with the man who eventually assassinated Trosky. Charlie took several snap- shots of him, and was taken out for a meal at Maxims at his ex- pense. This iooseness seemed doubly inapproprate when it was discovered that Clement, who had been the acting secreatry had been murdered. All the organisation went through his hands and he dis- appeared about a week before the conference. Eventually a letter turned up from him, saying that he was disillusioned with revolution- ary politics, and was going off to Spain to fight in the civil war. Of course the letter was a forgery as Trotsky argued immediately: his headiess body was found floating in the Seine.

The fact that this was a period of abject defeats was the reason, he thinks, that so many people at that conference fell by the wayside. People who were at that conference, like Max Shachman, who was chairing most of the meet- ings, Pablo from Greece, and the others, and Pierre Rousset's father, David, who eventualiy be came a Gaullist MP, could not stand the periods of retreats, especially after the second worid war, when the stalinist emerged as a much more powerful and long lasting force than had been an- ticipated.

Stalinism was incapable of developing marxist thought. Everything was dictated by Mos cow, had to be rubber stamped as bearing the correct line.Millions died in the Soviet Union without ever coming to trial, amongst them thousands of supporters of the Fourth International. And it is the case that all the innovative think- ing, which has tried to use the Mar- xist method to analyse contem- porary reality, or to deal with issues like feminism that have been manifested in new ways, have come from trotskyists or other non-

stalinist traditions

Charlie confesses that the question of women's role in revolu- tionary politics was not consciouly discussed or considered in those days. Despite the debates raised by Kollontai, and the massive fer ment around the German women's movement in the 1920's, Trotskyists in Britain and internationaliy did not seem con cerned to ensure that women were won to revolutionary politics, or played a key role when they were recruited. Even during the war, when the position of women in the workforce was changing dramati- cally and because of that women's position in the home, the sig- nificance of this did not occur to the trotskyists.Internally too, the situation was appaling, with very few wowmen involved in any of the leading bodies.

Perhaps the most exhillarating experience for Charlie came after the Congress itself. 'We were so optimistic about the future, that we founded a youth international, and we set up an international ex- ecutive committee, to which 1 was "elected'. At that time we had youth sections in America, France, the Netherlands, Britain and Bel- gium.The French youth played the decisive role in this. There was a remarkable French comrade, Hicks, a school teacher, who even- tually died in a German concentra tion camp, after organising marxist there. There were a number of comrades from America, the Youth alliance, Maggie Gould and others. As there has never been another conference, Charlie, at 75, is still a member of this Youth executive.

Charlie reminds us 'Trotsky his in diary in exile decided that he had no right to commit suicide because he was the living link between the Leninist past and future. My view then and now is that if we have ac- complished nothing else in the in- ternational, we have continued to serve as a link between the revolu- tionary policies of Marx, Engels, Lenin and Trotsky, and the next and present generations'

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 10 November 1988

Eileen Gersh & other students peel potatoes for hunger march

continued from page 15

programmes, however radical they may appear on the surface, which result in the working class looking to any sector of the ruling class for support in its historic struggle.

This central idea of class inde- pendence is based on, and sub- sequently confirmed by, the whole history of the twentieth century. It may seem elementary, but it lies at the heart of all the dif- ferences between revolutionary marxism and social democracy (whether left or right variants) and stalinism. Their practice and programmes are based on com- promise, collaboration and in- tegration with the bourgeoisie or sections of the bourgeoisie and its state institutions.

The issue of class inde- pendence is also one of the fun- damental divides between revolu- tionary marxism and populist or national liberation movements in the dependent countries, whose programmes have been more or less influenced by their ideas about alliances with "progressive" ', "democratic' and "anti-imperialist" sectors of the local ruling class.

Since 1938 history has shown us that old-fashioned class col laboration and 'popular frontism' can take on many guises which may fool the unwary and lead the workers and oppressed into ter- rible defeats. In the post-war period Greece, Indonesia and Por- tugal spring to mind. In all these cases mass revolutionary move- ments went down to defeat due, in part, to the adoption of 'popular frontist' policies. And there are many other examples of class col-

laboration which have resulted in demobilisation and defeat for the working class.

Some have challenged the marxist principle of class inde- pendence by pointing to the post- war revolutionary overturns of capitalism in the underdeveloped countries: revolutions which were not led by trotskyists. But whatever programme was formal- ly adhered to, the leaderships of all these revolutions rejected in practice any intermediate 'stage' of alliance with the bourgeoisie, or a section of the bourgeoisie, and broke with the ruling class and its state.

In Yugoslavia, China, Cuba and Vietnam, very different kinds of leadership with inadequate programmes, sometimes derived from the stalinist movement of which, with the exception of the Castro leadership in Cuba, they were a part, were nonetheless able to break with the capitalists and the 'popular frontist' strategies pursued by the traditional parties.

These post-war revolutionary overturns were not only opposed by Moscow - even the revolution- ary marxists were sometimes con- fused by political developments which did not seem to take a clas- sical form. This resulted in oppor- tunist or sectarian errors. Many trotskyists debated whether capitalism had in fact been over- thrown in, for example, countries like Yugoslavia or Cuba.

This reflected the fact that in the post-war period the interna- tional class struggle developed in a quite different way to that which the trotskyists expected in the late 1930s. Despite this, the key to un-

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 10 November 1988

derstanding the post-war

overturns is to be found in

the transitional

programme.

In the section entitled

'Workers and Farmers'

Government', the transi-

tional programme explains

that revolutionary marx-

ists must call on all those

leaderships, old and new,

who base themselves on

the workers and peasants,

and who claim to speak in

their name, to: 'break

politically from the bour- D MAIL

geoisie and enter upon the

road of struggle for the workers' and farmers' govern- ment. On this road we promise them full support against capitalist reaction. At the same time, we indefatigably develop agitation around those transition- al demands which should in our opinion form the programme of the 'workers' and farmers' government'.

Although the exact wording of the slogan can vary (for example, a governmental slogan which rested on an alliance with the peasantry or farmers in Britain today would be anachronistic!), the method adopted here is ap- plicable to both the imperialist countries and the semi-colonial world.

'Is the creation of such a government by the traditional workers' organisations possible?' asks Trotsky in the transitional programme. 'Past experience shows... that this isto say the least highly improbable. However, one cannot categorically deny in ad- vance the theoretical possibility that, under the influence of com- pletely exceptional circumstances (war, defeat, financial crash, mass revolutionary pressure, ete), the

petty-bourgeois parties including the stalinists may go further than they wish along the road to break with the bourgeoisie.' "However,' he continues, 'there is no need to indulge in guesswork. The agita- tion around the slogan of a workers'-farmers' government preserves under all conditions a tremendous educational value'.

The post-war revolutions have confirmed in real life that the stalinist and, in the case of the Cuban July 26th movement,

"the key to

understanding

the post-war

overturns is to be found in

the

transitional

programme."

"post-war

revolutionary

overturns were opposed

95 by Moscow...

Page 17

"Trotsky did not expect Mao's Red Army to come to anything."

"The tactic of the united front... was always a policy for defending and advancing the interests of the working class...

Page 18

UP P

L E M LEIN

I petty-bourgeois nationalist movements, can, in 'excep- tional circumstances', go fur- ther than they intended along the road to break with the bourgeoisie. This confirms what was in Trotsky's day

'theoretical only a possibility.

While the Castro leader- ship in 1959 represented a new type of non-stalinist force, the Mao leadership in China had its roots firmly in the stalinist tradition. In the 1930s Trotsky did not expect Mao's Red Army to come to anything.

However, momentous con- ditions - revolutionary war against the Japanese invasion and the nationalist Guomindang ar- mies, huge revolutionary pres- sures from the workers and peasants, economic catastrophe, the inability of imperialism to in- tervene at the end of the world war and so on - allowed the Mao leadership to make a decisive break with the bourgeoisie. All the other openings (some of which were tried) were progressively closed off to it.

The Cuban leadership at- tempted to establish a national bourgeois-democratic regime after the revolutionary overthrow of the hated dictator Batista, but the sabotage and hostility of the national capitalists in alliance with US imperialism, which or- ganised a blockade of Cuba, forced the Castro leadership to make a fundamental choice: to break with the bourgeois mini- sters in the government and em- bark on an anti-capitalist revolu- tion, or to capitulate to imperialist pressure. The momentous choice they made marks one of the great moments in working class history.

Unlike the Chinese or Yugos- lavian CPs, the Cuban July 26th

Mao: forced to break with the bourgeoise

movement did not have its roots in stalinism or social democracy. This is an important factor which, despite the subsequent develop- ment of the Cuban Communist Party under Castro and an increas- ing subordination to Moscow, has marked the political evolution of the Castro leadership till this day.

Other factors which led to a revolutionary outcome in Cuba, apart from the quality and in-

tegrity of the leadership, include the escalating mobilisations of the workers in Havana and on the plantations, the weakness and cor- ruption of the national bour- geoisie and its subordination to US interests, the incredible blunders of American im- perialism, and the willingness of Khrushchev's Kremlin leadership - for its own reasons - to lend economic and military support.

None of these individual ele- ments in and of themselves could have made an anti-capitalist revolution possible, but they came together and pointed to the only way way forward. The Castro movement was not weighed down with stalinist or social democratic prejudices, but neither, as a prag- matic and empirical movement, was it a marxist party with a coherent programme of proletarian revolution and socialist democracy.

Such a leadership cannot provide a programme nor act as a model for revolutionaries in our epoch, although the experience of the Cuban revolution can clarify the marxist programme and deepen our understanding of the revolutionary process.

The question that some marx- ists have raised in relation to these

revolutionary post-war breakthroughs is whether or not we can talk about exceptions' to a general rule. However distorted or bureaucratised these revolu- tions were - and they have all marked by a lack of in- stitutionalised working class power-maybe we have been a lit-

tle sectarian towards them? Should we not reassess our at- titude towards some political movements whose programme and origins lay within the stalinist or populist traditions?

This discourse has led to a variety of answers, and most of them end up challenging the validity of key aspects of the tran- sitional programme - on ques- tions of class independence, the popular front and the united front and on the theory of permanent revolution.

Another component of the tran- sitional programme which is as fundamental as class inde- pendence from the bourgeoisie, is the equally strategic question of class unity. The united front which is proposed is counterposed to all kinds of "popular fronts' or "people's fronts" with bourgeois parties as advocated by stalinist parties.

The tactic of the united front as originally formulated by the early Comintern under Lenin and Trotsky, was much more than a political manoeuvre or a literary technique to 'expose' the refusal of reformist bureaucrats to fight. It was always a policy for defend- ing and advancing the interests of the working class by seeking to unite its mass organisations and the non-aligned workers in a com- mon struggle against the bour- geoisie. The two inseparable tenets of this tactic are united ac- tion for any genuine step forward and the organisational and politi-

HIU HIL VIGHIIUAKULLI LIU PUIIE

cal independence of the revolu-

tionary party.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 10 November 1988

0004840008

Conditions do not exist in con- temporary Britain for this "classical' form of the united front because of the existence of a mass unitary labour movement. It is nevertheless essential that the marxist left seeks, wherever pos- sible, unity in action against the bosses. In other countries in Europe such as France, for ex- ample, where two mass workers' parties and trade union federa- tions exist, the issue of class unity and the united front against the bourgeoisie retains its full force, including at the governmental level.

Translated into today's condi- tions in Britain, the workers' government slogan, an expression of a united front approach, would be: 'Fora Labour government that breaks with the bosses and defends the workers', or a variant of this (the content given to any slogan is the crucial thing). In France it could be: 'For a Com- munist Party-Socialist Party government which defends the workers'. In response to the present Rocard government which represents a coalition be- tween the SP and a part of the right (and not the CP), marxists could call for: 'A government of the SP and CP without bourgeois ministers'

The united front tactic is neces- sary because of the divisions created within the working class. Unity in action is necessary not only within the walls of a single factory or industry, but also for such national political battles as the struggle against imperialist war, the fight against nuclear weapons and NATO.

This tactic also flows out of the need for marxist currents, which are not recognised as the leader- ship of the workers' movement, to prove to the masses that they are ready to wage a common battle with anyone, so long as it is a step, however small, along the historic road of the proletariat towards its expropriation of capital.

Perhaps the best-known aspect of the transitional programme is its advocacy of a 'system of tran- sitional demands, stemming from today's conditions and from today's consciousness of wide layers of the working class and unalterably leading to one final

S P MEIN

Spanish workers betrayed by Stalin

conclusion: the conquest of power by the proletariat.'

Such an approach is counter- posed to the traditional social democratic method of pursuing only a 'minimum' programme of reforms within capitalism, while leaving the 'maximum' programme of socialist transfor- mation to May day speeches and the distant future. The reformist 'minimum' programme provides no bridge to the maximum socialist programme - the ex- propriation of the capitalist and so on. Reformist leaders are scared to death of such an idea.

Yet in a period of capitalist crisis like the one we face today, there can be no prospect of sys- tematic social reforms, or the rais- ing of the living standards of the broad masses of people; every serious demand - even 'minimum' demands - has a ten- dency to reach beyond the limits of capitalist property relations and the bourgeois state. Here lies the origins of the profound crisis of 'Labourism'. The British Labour Party cannot find a reformist policy which is acceptable to the ruling class, and as a consequence the bureaucracy, scared of socialist solutions, is being dragged to the right.

"The strategic task of the Fourth International lies not in reforming capitalism but in its overthrow... (but it) does not discard the programme of the old "minimal"

demands.. it defends the democratic rights and social con- quests of the workers. But it car- ries on this day-to-day work within the framework of the cor- rect actual, that is, revolutionary perspective. Insofar as the old, partial, "minimal" demands of the masses clash with the destructive and degrading tendencies of capitalism - and this occurs at each step- the FI advances a sys- tem of transitional demands, the essence of which is contained in the fact that ever more openly and decisively they will be directed against the very basis of the bour- geois regime.'

The document adopted in 1938 discusses a whole array of such demands, from the sliding scale of wages (to protect the real value of wages against inflation through automatic increases), and the slid- ing scale of hours, to the ex- propriation of the monopolies and the banks and workers' control.

The transitional programme ar- gues that revolutionaries must re- late particularly to the most op- pressed layers of the working class, especially women and youth. 'Opportunist organisations by their very nature concentrate their chief attention on the top layers of the working class and therefore ignore both the youth and the woman worker ' One could also add the black worker... 'The decay of capitalism, however, deals its heaviest blows

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 10 November 1988

"Many

trotskyists

debated

whether capitalism had in fact been thrown

over in

countries

like Yugoslavia

or Cuba"

Page 19

S UP M E N

Kinnock's Labour Party: loyal to the market

"the transitional programme insists that revolutionaries should seek support 'among the most exploited layers of the working class; consequently among women workers""

Page 20

to the woman as a wage-earner and as a houeswife.' It insists that revolutionaries 'should seek bases of support among the most ex- ploited layers of the working class; consequently among the women workers.

Despite correct points in rela- tion to social layers who ex- perience a double oppression under capitalism, this section of the transitional programme ap- pears to us today the most under- developed. The continued integra- tion of women into the workforce during and after the second world war and therefore into society at large, created the conditions for the emergence of the modern women's liberation movement which has greatly enriched our un- derstanding of women's oppres- sion and an understanding of the centrality of the liberation of women for working class politics.

The 1938 programme includes more sections than we have space to discuss here. There are sections, for example, on the struggle against imperialism and war, combined and uneven develop- ment in the backward countries, and permanent revolution.

It is a document which repre- sents the distilled experience of a hundred years and more of the in- ternational class struggle. It is one of those texts which when reread always results in profitable new insights into the complex

WAYNE EDGINGTION

problems of socialist strategy. In particular, the opening section which focuses on the proletariat and its leadership, or more cor- rectly the crisis of working class leadership, rings particularly true today.

In Britain the crisis of leader- ship could not be more clear. Vir- tually the whole Labour and trade union leadership has shifted its ground to the right and now sub- scribes to so-called 'new realism' in reality, old-fashioned class collaboration under a new name. Even after the defeat of the miners' strike, the willingness of section after section of the class to move into struggle (albeit defen- sive struggle) is obvious. But on every occasion these workers have come up against a national leadership that will not lead a fight.

The same story is repeated in many parts of the globe, some- times leading to catastrophic con- sequences. 'In all countries the proletariat is racked by a deep dis- quiet. The multimillioned masses again and again enter the road of revolution. But each time they are blocked by their own conservative bureaucratic machines."

In the advanced capitalist countries it is the leaderships of the traditional workers' organisa- tions which act as a barrier to socialist advance. "The orienta- tion of the masses is determined first by the objective conditions of

decaying capitalism, and second, by the treacherous politics of the old workers' organisations, ex- plains the transitional programme.

But to challenge these leader- ships, the revolutionary marxists must reject sectarianism. In the section entitled 'Against Sec- tarianism, the text explains that 'under the influence of the betrayal by the historic organisa- tions of the proletariat, certain sectarian moods and groupings of various kinds arise... Attheir base lies a refusal to struggle for partial and transitional demands, ie for the elementary interests and needs of the working masses, as they are today... They propose turning their backs on the old trade unions... They remain indifferent to the inner struggle within the reformist organisations — as if one could win the masses without in- tervening in their daily strife!'

It's a pity that so many self- proclaimed revolutionaries in Britain have not taken this advice, and have found themselves on the sidelines of so much strife in the labour movement in recent years.

Dave Packer

All quotes are from The Death Agony of Capitalism and the Tasks of the Fourth Internation- al, New Park publications.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 10 November 1988

← A programme for our times · Marxism on green terrain →

Something wrong on this page?