telecommunications industry, based on renationalisation and workers management.
las tailed to combat
naustry and drastically argues, is for the
strategy. which mobilisation of the rol and a sucialist plan
based on renationalisation and
The solutions are also depressingly fami- liar, a drive on 'productivity' (exploitation) and massive job loss. Out of a workforce of 236,000, a total of 70,000 jobs are said to be under threat by the early 1990s.
This programme requires the decisive weakening of the dominant BT union, the NCU, and of its militant left wing in the big cities in particular. In this project manage- ment have an able and determined ally in John Golding, the union's general secretary. Golding is the first union general secretary to gain office as a direct result of the Tory anti-union laws on balloting. He and the "NCU First" right-wing want a small highly paid NCU membership in BT. This would be
THE GROWTH AND technological conver- gence of the telecommunications and com- puter industries is one of the major features of the restructuring of the world capitalist economy. The world-wide gro... tele communications of 8 per cent per annum offers mouthwatering opportunities for profit hungry multinationals in a period of slow economic growth.
Hitherto telecommunications has been dominated by state monopolies such as the old Post Office in the UK or by state regulated private monopolies such as AT & 1 (Ma Bell) in the USA. The ambitions of the multinationals are also worldwide. The big players in the scramble are led by IBM with an annual turnover of over $50 billion and the slightly smaller AT & T, now divested of its local us telephone companies - the Baby Bells' -- each of which is as big as BT.
In this league BT is a relative minnow, seven or eight times smaller than IBM. It is however, hugely profitable on the basis of its continued monopoly of Uk telecommunica- tions. Its £2.2 billion estimated 1986/87 pro- fit represents a massive 20 per cent rate of return on capital, compared with British capital's average of 5% or so.
There are nevertheless clouds on the hori zon. BT is relatively technologically back ward compared with even its French and German counterparts. It will only complete the installation ur electrom digitalised exchange equipment in the early 1990s. Its rate of investment is half that of the French network. It operates only 89 lines per employee compared with 140 in France. BT makes the bulk of its current profits from call revenue, and in particular from trunk and international calls. The Mercury company will soon have the capability to provide a serious alternative for business users. Iro- nically, fierce competition in this area in the USA means that carriers are now losing money, where they expected to make fat profits. BT is already losing market share in the provision and maintenance of private
- minnow
IBN
Dasıs of 1s Inumunl
rate u
John Golding, witchfinder general of the NCU
switchboards and telephones. A high per- centage of BT staff are employed in these
fields
Thus the familiar pattern of much of British industry is reemerging - low and declining investment and productivity com- pared with its competitors, protected only in the medium term by its continued monopoly
position in the local networks. Even this Pusition
monopoly is threatened with the develop- monopol
ment of mobile radiotelephones, satellite, and cable.
achieved by productivity bargaining and a voluntary redundancy agreement. Thus, for the leadership the only question during the recent strike was the cost of the strings. As an effectively single union employer, substantial redundancies in BT would bring into ques- tion the NCU's viability as an independent union. The prospect of a link up with the EEPTU may be posed
But Golding faces many obstacles. The union membership is very young the average age is under 35 - with specialised
Socialist Outlook. No 1 May/June 1987
Denis Doran/Reflex
skills. Junr: ndancy voluntary reurement • not an option for many. The strike has not demora- lised the bulk of the membership, and a new layer of militants is coming forward. internal regime of the union is relatively democratic - for example any branch has the unrestricted right to circulate material to other branches. The full time apparatus is relatively small. The big city branches are left-led and are openly hostile to the national leadership, and capable of limited indepen- dent action. During the recent strike BT was only forced into negotiations after the 20,000 strong demonstration called by the union's City of London district council threatened to loosen the leadership's control over the strike.
attrachve i demora- ind a new
The Broad Left The left in the union is organised through the Broad Left, an increasingly uneasy coalition including Kinnockites. Militant, a substantial layer of independent lett: nd a sprinkling of marxists. It came into existence after the 1978 35-hour-week campaign. Its greatest triumph was its sweeping to office in the middle of the 1983 anti-privatisation action (in general election week).
Unfortunately, the adoption of a strategy of selective industrial action proved disas- trous and within six months the Broad Left majority on the NEC collapsed in front of the Mercury injunction and the prospect of sequestration. This set the scene, for the remainder of its period of office, for avoi- dance of confrontation with BT (and the Post Office) apart from a half-hearted campaign on the 1985 pay claim. One major missed opportunity was a fight over the 'broad strategy', and centrally its call for a 32-hour, 4-day week to meet the threat to jobs posed by the new technology, privatisation and competition.
Thus with some honourable exceptions, the BL NEC demoralised and demobilised its supporters, creating the conditions for Gold- ing and the right to sweep back in 1986. The Broad Left's failure in office was a conse- quence of its political and organisational limitations — primarily an electoral machine and conference caucus. The BL organisation itself stagnated during the period 1983-86. Many branch officers and activists took a passive or cynical line towards the national leadership.
During the recent strike the London Broad Left initiated the Coordinating Committee of London branches — an important step but one which never realised its potential. It also produced information and leaflets on the course of the strike. But no more than a handful of activists were involved, many of the traditional supporters being wrapped up in local problems. Tnus the impact of the Broad Left was weak. It must be said that this was not helped by the sectarian and absten- tionist attitudes of some of the marxist groups.
The Broad Left needs to transform itself into a truly mass force in order to lead the union to take on an aggressive BT manage- ment and the new cynics at Greystoke House, the union HQ. That means breaking
1 itsel ad the anage-
Socialist Outlook No 1 May/June 1987
UNIONS
Party
to wnich both the Communist
Party and Militant
subscribed. BT management knows that it
needs to break the union in the strategic City
district and has decided to victimise leading
militants there. A defence campaign includ- ing national strike action is clearly required This should be a central feature of the Broad Left's NEC election campaign.
u. DI IN
and maint
Labour's social ownership proposals for BT The future of BT and its workers is bound up with the general election and Labour's social ownership proposals. We need to have a clear attitude towards these policies. There are two stages in Labour's plan for BT. First to use the government's 49 per cent shareholding to ensure sumer protection. industrial democracy, research and development, and to ensure that telecommunications and infor- mation technology are developed in 'the best interests of Britain'. This will be followed 'as
soon as parliamentary time permits' by 'full
'the future of BT and its workers is bound up with the general election and Labour's social ownership proposals'
scale sucial ownership'
- essentially swapping of non-voting
securities for BT shares. These would still be issued by BT and their price tied to BT's profit performance. The board would be appointed by, and answerable to, the secretary of state.
By 'industrial democracy' is meant the appointment by the secretary of state of a 'significant' number of BT workers and con- sumers to seats on the national and district boards, 'the size and scope of such represen-
tation to be open to discussion and agree-
ment' (with whom?). The clear intent is that these will be a minority of seats - along West German lines.
BT's network monopoly would be restored and Mercury integrated into it. However, the monopoly will not be restored in the
customer equipment field (telephones, telex,
fax and so forth), thus continuing to subject a
large proportion of BT staff to the icy blasts of
cut-throat competition in these fields.
These proposals are utterly inadequate
utterly inadequate
and dangerous. Not only are the capitalists to
be fully compensated, but BT will clearly be
expected to maximise profit at the expense of
consumers and workers, despite the waffle
1 responsibunty. Ine industrial
democracy proposals are window dressing
since the worker/consumer representatives
would be outvoted on any contentious issue.
Needless to say there is no mention of sacking
the exising board members or higher mana-
gement, despite their being totally com- mitted to privatisation, as shown in the
recent fight against the unions. Additionally,
any socialist strategy would have to natio-
cus" fax
arge cut-t
) nI
cun
an
→ LE
neil atic
nalise the major telecommunications suppliers such as Plessey, GEC and STC
On the other hand Labour's proposals will be fiercely resisted by the City of London and BT management. BT is too rich a prize to let slip, even if Roy Hattersley is happy to let them take the money. The City and BT insist on nothing less than the full control implied by voting shares. They don't trust any gov- ernment with their money, least of all a government which mouths off about "social responsibility'. It would be necessary to de- fend a Labour government against the capi- talists' sabotage if it ever acted on its vaguely worded promises.
Militant has put forward the only alterna- tive programme to Labour's utopias. Militant proposes that a Labour government should reconstitute the BT boards of management with one-third representatives of the workers, one-third from the TUC, and one- third from the government. Lower manage- ment personnel and structures would be left intact. This they say would constitute 'a form of workers' management'. But Militant does not make it clear that such an arrangement could only be successfully applied in a planned economy. Otherwise such a board would be compelled by the same 'market forces' to take many of the same anti- working class decisions as the present one. Militant's plan is a measure to be imple- mented by a Labour government entirely divorced from the actual course of struggle of the workers themselves. In no way does this plan inform current strategies in the fight against BT management. In this sense it is not qualitatively different from Labour's policy.
Any plan for workers' control must start from the needs of the struggle, centreing on such traditional demands as opening of the books and the imposition of workers' vetoes on management prerogatives. BT unions in association with other telecommunication and communication workers need to draw up a plan based on social need along the lines of the Lucas Aerospace plan, to combat the plans of the 'communications' multina- tionals. Otherwise we leave the highground to our opponents, reacting in purely defens- ive kneejerk ways to their well thought out strategies. A start to a discussion on the future of the world telecommunications in- dustry has been made at a recent conference in Holland organised by the Transnational Institute.
The NCU strike has brought into united action for the first time a powerful section of the working class, which is right in the middle of the information technology revolu- tion. Its members are fighting not only on pay, jobs and conditions, but for the very survival of independent trade unionism in the industry. In future confrontations BT will be better prepared, having brought into service more reliable System X and Y exchanges, and a housetrained management scab force. We will need the support and solidarity of the working class and the op- pressed for our future struggles. Any 'go it alone' strategies are doomed to failure. That means we have now to extend our support to their struggles and break with the inward- looking attitudes of the past.
5
116
IRELAND
Ireland: the cause of labour?
FACTUAL ACCOUNTS of employment discri- mination on a sectarian basis in the north have been published in a variety of docu- ments, ranging from those produced by gov- ernment agencies to republican newspapers.
The division of the working class in Ire- land is not new. It was being cultivated by the British as far back as the early eighteenth century, when the south was the centre of industrial capitalism and Ulster the indus- trially backward and revolutionary part of the country. By the end of that century, though, this order of ascenaanev Was in reverse with a more dominant north and backward south.
As in Britain, the rise of industrial capital- ism went hand in hand with the growth of the early craft unions which, in Belfast, were essentially Protestant organisations. They were beginning to reflect the class structure of Ireland at that time. Divisions began to emerge on a craft and religious basis: Prote- stant and more skilled; Catholic and less skilled. Despite this early start, the trade union movement in the six counties did not win official recognition until 1964
There are currently about 300,000 union members in the north of Ireland, of whom 80-90 per cent are in unions which are affiliated to the Northern Ireland Committee of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions (ICTU), but have their headquarters in Bri- tain. (The NIC was set up in 1944 to deal specifically with problems relating to the north).
The union structure in Ireland is not. however, straightforward. Some of tne unions operate only in the north and are affiliated to the TUC. Others operate both in the north and the south. There are a few with membership in the north which are not affiliated to either the ICTU or the TUC. To add to the confusion, a few have their head- quarters in the twenty-six counties, have members in the north but are not affiliated to the ICTU. There is no bar on British-based unions being affiliated to both the TUC and the ICTU.
Despite this organisational complexity, one element is dominant: the role of the British trade unions in the six counties.
Their record there has not been a proud one. It has, in short, been one of very selective activity, having found little to say about civil rights, internment, Bloody Sun- day, violations of human rights or sectarian- ism in the workplace.
Yet the trade unions claim to be 'the most representative body in the province, embrac- ing all sections of religious and political opinion' (in the NIC's 'ICTU: Role and Func- tions'). That being the case, why has this united band of 300,000 not yet achieved anything of significance in the six counties. The answer is that the NIC and ICTU are deluding themselves. They may well repre- sent some 300,000 people but they are a people who have been historically and cul- turally divided.
A major trade union conference on employment discrimination in
the six counties is being held in November. Along with campaigning around the general election, this conference is the main focus of Irish solidarity work in the next year. Here, ALISON CLARKE of the Labour Cornmittee on Ireland trade union department, explains why the issue must be raised in the trade union movement.
(ohn
unionism and Unionism, the sectarian combination
onisn
the sectarian
When the unions claim to be non-sectarian
sectarian to the Protestant majority in the north. When they claim to be non-political, what they mean is that they adhere to the accepted status quo, ie that of the Unionists.
can • non- ajoriry in thr nor . adhere to une he Unionists. orerest that to
.membership
They covet these labels on the pretext that to do otherwise would split the membership
Nor is it any wonder that they adopt this line, given the way the employment scales
i thev adopt this
line, given the way the employment scales are tipped in favour of their majority mem-
bership. The level of unemployment among
Catholic men is two and a half times that
among Protestant men. Catholics are under- represented in engineering, utilities, bank- ing, finance and business and have an un- healthy over-dependence on the construction industry.
Among women, the ratio of unemploy- ment for Catholics is one and a half times that of their Protestant counterparts. Although these statistics suggest a better deal for women than men, they in fact obscure the double oppression experienced by Catholic
women.
As a result, the low participation rates of women in the province due to strong reli- gious and social influences are overlooked; the low numbers of women returning to the labour force after completing a family are
ignored; the relative immobility of women in terms of looking for work is marginalised as a factor in women's employment experience. And the reluctance of women to register as unemployed is missed. This is to say nothing of the types of industries in which women predominantly tind work and the part-time, low paid, low status work open to them
Employment discrimination against the Catholic community in the six counties has endured - and is getting worse, not better - despite the progressive convergence of educational achievement between the two communities, and despite the passage of the Fair Employment legislation through Parlia- ment 11 years ago.
And yet the issue is not discussed by the British trade union movement which do- minates the scene in the north of Ireland. It is the Protestants, as a small minority in British trade unions, who dictate to the majority membership what the policies of our unions will be and even what topics are fit for discussion.
But equal opportunities are the proper concern of our trade union movement. It is the job of the unions to combat discrimina- tion of any variety - be it sexual, racial or religious
'