UNIONS
Clive Jenkins looking peekish around the Gills
TASSIASTMS MERGER
THE ASSOCIATION of Scientific Technical and Managerial Staffs (ASTMS) and the Technical and Supervisory Staffs (TASS) are the largest 'white collar' unions in the private sector. Their merging is a major challenge for the memberships involved: it could either mean a strengthening of their hand, or rein- force bureaucratic control. It may be a step forward or a massive mistake!
The logic of the merger is obvious - both unions organise in the technical grades of engineering. In fact the proposal to merge came from the ASTMS Engineering Confe- rence. The members work alongside each other; and the officials of both unions go into joint negotiations with management for members in the same factories. The logic however is not quite so obvious to other sections of the unions. The ASTMS Insurance Sections, health workers and university tech- nicians - including some of the lowest-paid and most militant membership - have no contact with TASS.
The TASS Tobacco workers do not have ASTMS counterparts either; but they are a similar type of member, and if the incredible mixture that makes up a hybrid union like ASTMS can work, then the addition of members from TASS (which is the smaller of the two should be easy.
The real problem is the totally different structures and histories of the two unions. ASTMS has a relatively open democratic structure (as far as that is possible within the confines of a bureaucratic trade union move- ment). It has a large annual delegate confe- rence (made up from over 1000 branch delegates); elected lay delegates represent ASTMS at both the TUC Congress and the Labour Party conference; ASTMS even elects its representative on the TUC.
The Broad Left within ASTMS is a vague unstructured organisation based on left ac- tivists. In its heyday it has been viciously
Socialist Outlook No 1 May/June 1987
THE proposed merger of ASTMS and TASS could this year create a new union nearly as large as the AEU, and challenge NALGO's status as the largest white collar
union in Britain. ANNE SOMERS assesses the prospects
for the new union.
witch hunted by Clive Jenkins' rightward- moving leadership; but under pressure from Militant and the SWP it has decued in strength among independent activists, and now doesn't meet regularly (if at all) any
more. ASTMS as a whole is a strange mixture
of politics, reflecting its mixture of mana- gerial and supervisory staff with working technicians. Although the leadership is right wing and dominates through the bureau- cracy it has never been able to totally strangle the left.
TASS on the other hand has a very bureaucratic structure. It has a small confe- rence (about 160 delegates) that is elected at district conferences. The size of the confe- rence makes it very easy for the bureaucracy to control, and most of its representatives are selected at that conference. The TASS Broad Left is effectively the machinery through which Ken Gill's Morning Star wing of the Communist Party has traditionally con- trolled the union. The entire national execut- ive and over 95% of the conference delegates are members of the Broad Left (or they wouldn't get elected).
The Broad Left is more broad then left. Statements that 'anyone can join the Broad Left' are closely followed by the proviso: 'well, any one except Trotskyists or anarch-
ists.' TASS is a union that is built around its history of a Communist Party leadership - it has a Stalinist structure.
The writing is already on the wall for the left. TASS NEC members and full-time of- ficials have already regularly announced that after the merger they will deal with the Trots' in ASTMS. They have a certain amount of contempt for the ASTMS NEC, who have not only not 'dealt with' the "Trots', but have an NEC member who is a Trotskyist! This anomaly stems from the fact that ASTMS has elections for its NEC — most of which are contested - and Sue Lister, a known Trots- kyist, won a secret postal ballot for one of the two natonal seats TASS NFC members however, are not usually contested; so they don't have elections! (This is how they man- age to 'defy' the Tory anti-union laws with- out themselves having to break the law!)
If the combined unions were to end up with the best points of both unions - mostly ASTMS structures — then the merger would not only be a logical development but also a positive step forward. It will create a large union which will be potentially left wing, and could have an input into engineering that would counter the AEU and EETPU. The ASTMS leadership, however, though having far more members, are no political match for the well-oiled burcaucratic machine of Ken Gill's 'Broad Left'. The political direction of the new merged union would swiftly pass towards the TASS leader- ship - whose contempt for even the most elementary principles of working class soli- darity has been shown by their appalling victimisation of jailed anti-apartheid fighter David Kitson.
If the new union ends up being strangled by this bureaucracy, it could destroy the best elements of both ASTMS and TASS, becoming a left-talking but essentially right wing obstacle to any real fight by its members.
1
BROADWATER FARM
THE LIFE CONVICTIONS of Winston Silcott,
Mark Braithwaite and Engin Raghip for the murder of PC Blakelock during the Broad- water Farm (BWF) uprising mark a new stage of the relationship between the state and black people in Britain. The message behind the veritable police-judicial-media 'conspira- cy' against the Blakelock defendants is clear:
attempt to protest against police abuses of your human and democratic rights and you will pay the heaviest penalty.
Over the past 18 months, a number of black people have been either killed or seriously injured at the hands of the police — Cynthia Jarrett, Cherry Groce, Antony Le- mard, Clinton McCurbin, Trevor Monervil- le. Not a single policeman has been convicted of any offence. In fact DC Randall, who led the raid on Mrs Jarrett's home during which she died has since been promoted. This contrasts starkly with the treatment of defen- dants in the BWF trial. It exposes the dual standard intrinsic to British justice: the ease with which inspector Lovelock who shot and paralysed Cherry Groce was found 'not guil- ty' of maliciously wounding her at his trial and the treatment meted out to the Blakelock defendants are two sides of the same coin.
The repressive extra-legal nature of the police investigation and the legal process which culminated in the murder trials has been well documented and exposed by the BWF defence committee and the Broadwater Farm Youth Association BWFYA. Direct parallels with the repression of the nationalist community in the north of Ireland can be made from the deployment of plastic bullets on the night of the uprising to the stationing of army surplus Saracens at Tottenham police station following the Blakelock ver- dict. A clear and conscious link has been made publicly by the BWFYA leadership be- tween the British support for the South African regime and its 'apartheid-like' acti- vities at home.
In understanding the origins of the upris- ing and meaning of the convictions the fol- lowing are key pieces of the jigsaw: • The Gifford enquiry showed that it was the police refusal to even suspend any of the officers involved in the raid on Mrs Jarrett's home which led to the peaceful demonstra- tion making its way to the police station. This demonstration was stopped by riot police on the edge of the estate who then sealed it off. It was only then that disturbances ensued. The police assertion that the uprising was a 'pre- planned' operation has never been sustained in any way — not a single piece of evidence or independent eye-witness has been brought forward to support their claims. Attempts to portray the estate as a 'nest of thieves' conflict with the low crime figures on the estate. • DC Randall, who led the raid on Mrs Jarrett's house, and DC Sergeant who was involved in the interrogation of those ar- rested, were transferred to Tottenham from the notorious Stoke Newington police station in the clearout of eight "bad apples' following the suspicious death of Colin Roach. It was revealed in court that in March 1986 a man 2 was awarded £3,500 in damages at county
Broadwater Farm trials