would be to maximise the vote of the Alliance. Now, even if you take a simple anti-Tory stance, without any qualms about working class principle, you have to work out whether maximising the vote of the Alliance would mean maximising the anti-Tory vote. You also have to work out what its long term effects would be.
It is a simple fact that the main strategic objective of the Alliance is to marginalise and supplant Labour. It is the very bedrock of its outlook. If you believed Eric Hobsbawm you would think that the Alliance was burning with anti-Tory zealotry, and dying to come to an understanding with the Labour Party. But Hobsbawm is caught up in a world of his own schemas and
fantasies, without understanding the real political process at work. The long-term effect of maximising the Alliance vote would be to aid Dr Owen in his objective of dealing further blows against Labour. There is no hope of a share of power for the Alliance while it is the third party. Once it overtakes Labour, then its prospects are transformed.
Maybe it matters not a jot to Marxism Today and the Communist Party whether Labour is supplanted by the Alliance or not. But for those who detect a difference between the Alliance and Labour - the difference between a capitalist party pure and simple and a party which is based on the organised working class - then the strengthening of the Alliance at Labour's expense is a matter of some concern — a simple matter of the future of the British labour movement and working class struggle. But Marxism Today gave up worrying about that a long time ago. That's why we shall see its followers happily casting their 'Communist' votes for David Owen and all his anti-working class fervour •
Hobsbawm's choice?
ERIC HOBSBAWM, by advocating tactical Marxism Today, ha: all his disclaimers a wanting a coalition government really worthless. Marxists used to accuse Marxism T-... 'Euro' wing ul the vir to the right or wolt- uf the lavuur move some questions ch. to the right of in leadership itself.
Embarrasing!:
the Labour Party's own magazine. Now..... dreadful rigntwaru affair unger editor Weir also scen. advocating tacular Isn't there sometn. wnole HobsDawn, that the best wa.... Thatcher is bv v..r. non-Tory candidi best placed? Even terms
Il consuel auun» principle the a fatuous.
In the
urst plar
tactical voters sat supporters shoul candidate who is to defeat the Tur do you work our "n placed'? In the Greenwich by-elecuon this won been a very difficult calculation.
Second, the argument seems to assume that the objective of all the main
opposition partes 1s pr-
to get rid of Thatcher' as an everriding politicas
of course is just not true of the Alliance. The objective of the Alliance is to maximise its ene rutt, wilatever the outcome of the election. If maximising its own vote
means letting Mrs Thatcher in, so be it. This of course is exactly what the Alliance did in 1983. If "tactical voting' really caught on, the Alliance would use it just as much against the Labour Party as
against the Tories - and
indeed did just that during the Greenwich by-election. In
Black sections witch hunt
'SHADDUP' SNARLED Neil Kinnock when asked by TV news what his response was to
critics of the decision to
remove Sharon Atkin as the
candidate for Nottingham East.
The increasingly thuggish
response of Kinnock and his
lieutenants to Labour Party
Black Section and all internal
dissent inside the party shows
just how far the move to the
right and the witch hunt has gone.
On BBC's Newsnight
Meather. erstwhile
aligned, in theory at least, with Tony Benn, explained that the NEC couldn't tolerate a candidate who accused the Labour Party
racist.
Well, in truth, didn't ar An i go over the
cusation that the
P'arer was racist? Not
Andrew Moore/Reflex
Linda Bellos
at all. The Labour Party leadership and successive Labour governments have shown themselves to be racist to the core. Labour governments have tolerated racist immigration laws, and indeed tightened them up. A Labour government tolerated
the massive use of police violence against the black women strikers at Grunwick. It was under a Labour government that thousands of police were deployed to protect National Front. And successive Labour governments have done nothing whatever to improve the position of black people in British society.
That of course is something completely different to saying that all Labour Party members are racist, which of course is far from the truth, and something that Sharon Atkin never said. But the present Labour leadership has shown its racism in its response to Black Section. The arguments used by Roy Hattersley, a grubby and corrupt machine politician if ever there was one, to counter
Socialist Outlook No 1 May/June 1987