Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Terrorism

· International no. 8, January–February 1987 · pp 21-24 · 1,966 words

United States Latin America Britain

XTRA

20

35

25%

left-wing ignorance

Reagan administration's counter-revolutionary crusade. But, argues COLIN SMITH, it is not enough for the left to oppose Office his administration's main foreign policy concerns have been to restore the political, economic and military predominance of the US over the rest of the capitalist world and in particular over the sometimes rather recalcitrant allies in Western Europe. From the imposition of cruise missiles and support for Star Wars to full connivance in the attack on Libya the Thatcher government has been a willing helpmate in the revival of American power. It is no surprise therefore that Thatcher has also been the most enthusiastic champion of Reagan's ideological offensive on terrorism in the prime ministerial offices of Europe.

It is one of the most obvious aims of Reagan's offensive to use terrorism as a means to rob the popular struggles for national liberation of their political

Brute force and

"The fight against terrorism' has become the slogan of the

Reagan. It has to work out its own attitude to the reality of terrorism, and not be seen to condone or support it.

EVER SINCE Reagan sat in the Oval and moral legitimacy; to attempt to criminalise before Western public opinion all movements currently engaged in forms of armed struggle as well as most of those countries in the Third

World who have in recent history overthrown imperialist backed regimes — Cuba, Nicaragua, Angola for example. Discussion as to the conditions and causes that lie behind armed struggles are violently suppressed.

When George Schultz was urged recently by the Yugoslav foreign minister to look into the causes for Palestinian violence he fell into a fit of rage, pounding the table he announced

"There is no connection with any cause

- it's wrong'. Under this sort of schema the sole perpetrators of armed violence are evil men and women manipulated by anti-American, mostly pro-Sovie states (Reagan gave the list in July 1985 - Libya, Cuba,

North Korea, Nicaragua and Iran to which must now be added Syria) behind which looms the evil of evils, the Soviet Union

The Reaganite anti-terrorism offensive however has been given the aura of legitimacy not just by denouncing liberation movements as 'terrorists' but by the fact that there is such a thing as terrorism, and many of its actions are rightly abhored by ordinary people. In order for socialists to combat the Reagan-Thatcher offensive, it is necessary to clearly distance ourselves from terrorist actions, and to point out the difference between the small and isolated terrorist groups and mass liberation movements.

Among those who fall under the

International No 8 January/February 1987

catch-all of 'terrorism', it is possible to discern a variety of very different movements. First, there are genuinely terrorist groups, which may claim to act on behalf of the working class or 'the people', but are in fact elitist, militaristic sects with no or little connection with the workers movement. These include the Red Army Faction in Germany, the Red Brigades in Italy, or 'Action Directe' in France.

Then there are groups which have their origins in national liberation movements, which have subsequently degenerated into pure terrorism, and may be manipulated by state security agencies. The Abu Nidal group, operating out of Syria and at the behest of the Syrian security services is a classic International No 8 January/February 1987 example.

Third are genuine national liberation mcments utilising armed struggle as an adjunct to mass political struggle - the Provisional IRA and ETA in the Basque country fall into this category

In addition to this list are right wing terrorist groups trying to create a 'state of tension' provoking repression against the left — the bombings carried out by Italian fascist groups in the early 1970s are examples of this.

The groups which really are terrorist', even when made up of sincere militants who are not manipulated by state agencies — and this was certainly the case with the Red Army faction and the Red Brigades during their

WIMPY

The Oxford Street Wimpy bombing. initial stages — almost by definition fall prey to militarist deviations. In other words, they fall into the trap of judging everything by military 'success' abstracted from political considerations.

The need to preserve secrecy, protect safe houses, carry out bank raids to get money and conduct raids on arsenals to get weapons become the prime considerations. Military organisation inevitably produces a commandist structure which prevents any debate on political objectives, let alone a dialogue with currents in the workers movement.

This invariably produces an arrogant and contemptuous attitude to the workers movement itself and all forms

U of legal political activity. More and

'left wing' terrorist groups get cut off from their original objectives, and become prey to being used directly or indirectly by the state — either diagents, or indirectly through being the excuse for introducing repressive legislation. Inevitably such groups substitute themselves for the organised political activity of the working class. And often workers themselves can become the victims of terrorist bombings and shootings.

Armed actions by working class organisations where there is a military dictatorship, or indeed the activity of 'urban guerrillas' in Latin are a more complex question. example, in Chile today both Manual Rodriquez Patriotic Front) and the MIR (Movement of the Revolutionary Left) carry on some armed aside the overall politics of both these parties, with which we sharply disagree, ciple it is not incorrect to wage an armed struggle as an adjunct to, part of, an overall struggle to bring

The point here is that such activity must contribute to, rather than obstruct, the self-activity and organisation of the working class. Military activity of this sort has to be understandable both by working class militants and broader sectors of the workers movement. El Salvador is a clear case of the integration of armed struggle and mass organisation.

In general, armed activity, even by organisations with mass support, will not be understandable when there are democratic liberties mass political action and workers self-organisation to take place. In such circumstances armed action often degenerates and brings down harsh repression. A classic example is the fate of the Montoneros, the left wing Peronist urban guerrillas in Argentina. power of Peron in 1973 the Montoneros built mass support, organised in broad fronts for youth, workers and other groups. Peronist demonstrations were often dominated by the Montoneros — to the fury of the trade union bosses and Peron roundly denounced them.

But the Montoneros continued their clandestine urban guerrilla struggle.

their armed was taken over by military rather than 'politicos'. Indeed state repression led to the deaths of most of the more experienced political leaders. The guerrillas turned to executions of corrupt trade union bosses, actions not understood by the workers. internal discipline led to executions of 22 guerrillas who had given away infor-

P P E M mation under torture. And the needs of being militarily successful overrode political considerations.

Instead of activity aimed at preparing the workers, politically and militarily, for an impending military coup, the Montoneros, and the smaller ERP 'Guevarists', acted on the illusion that the guerrillas themselves could confront the full military might of the

When the army coup actually came in 1976 this proved to be a hopeless illusion. In fact the guerrilla war had demoralised and disorientated the mass of the working class, leaving them 'softened up' for the full savagery of the army's 'dirty war; after 1976 when up to people were slaughtered by the military.

A similar balance sheet could be drawn up of other urban guerrilla groups, such as the Uruguayan Tupamaros, an organisation which waged perhaps the most successful urban guerrilla struggle in the 1970s, but which was incapable of turning large scale but passive support into mass political organisation of the workers.

subordinating. armed action to mass organisation and political objectives must also apply to national liberation movements, even if terrorism if often the price for the failure of workers' struggles their armed struggle is already complemented by organisation. Otherwise, bombings and shootings can be turned into political weapons in the hands of reaction. It is hard to explain for example what political purpose the IRA Birmingham bombings in 1974 served and how they contributed to the defeat of British imperialism.

Although it would be dangerous to adopt alarmist positions on the current influence of this Reaganite offensive, it is undoubtedly true that such terrorist activities such as hijackings, kidnapping hostages, apparently random bombings and shootings - particularly of civilians — are met with revulsion by the great majority of people in Western Europe. These events have more than a passing resemblance to atrocities of gang warfare and the mafia especially to an audience that has little or no real experience of the bloody brutalities of the class struggle and daily life in for example the Middle East or parts of Central and South America. The fact that these acts are committed in the name of 'national liberation' or of 'socialist revolution' does not at all mean that there is not more than a kernel of moral and political truth in his popular detestation.

N

In this situation what should the position of socialists and Marxists be? We are faced here perhaps with a Scylla and Charybdis between which we must steer. On the one hand we must avoid giving any credence to the ideooffensive of Reagan Thatcher which would promote reaction and be tantamount to reneging on our duty to build support for genuine struggles for national liberation and

On the other hand we must also keep away from seeming in any way to condone the activities of such terrorist groups as the Abu Nidal faction, The Red Army Faction in West Germany or Action Directe in France.

Terrorism is often the price which the workers movement or national liberation movements pay for failure. The Red Brigades in Italy arose out of the frustration of a decade of titanic struggles which, because of the suffocating influence of the Italian Communist Party, resulted in very little in terms of advance for the left. And obviously the turn of some sections of the Palestinian movement towards terror tactics is a product of the defeat of more than a decade of armed struggle, and the desperation which the repeated massacres of Palestinians have wrought among many in the Palesti-

Thus in distancing ourselves from terrorism, socialists have to point the finger at those who are the real underlying cause of terrorist activity - in the first place imperialism, and particularly United States imperialism itself. The hypocrisy of Reagan waging a crusade against 'terrorism' while supporting the contras in Nicaragua dozens of similar counterrevolutionary cut-throat movements will not be lost on either readers of this journal, or millions of people world-

Even if we oppose terrorism on political and even moral grounds, the opposition of socialists is not equivalent to pacifism and disavowal of all use of arms. In crimes against the innocent, in crimes against humanity, in the spilling of blood by the millions of bucketfuls, imperialism has nothing to teach even the most wanton and reckless terrorist. The use of force is an inevitability in bringing down this system of organised butchery. But in attempting to turn this fact into a guide to immediate action, whatever the circumstances, terrorism results in violence using the wrong methods, at the wrong time, and often against the wrong people.

Those who practice it are the enemies of revolutionary socialism, which is based on the notion that the liberation of the working class is the activity of the working class itself - not that o: self-proclaimed armed vanguards. d

International No 8 January/February 19:

← AIDS · All the President's men — pt II →

Something wrong on this page?