Liberal shibboleths of the cuddly left
CHRIS BERTRAM Peter Hain, Proportional Misrepresentation: the case against PR in Britain, Wildwood House, £5.95. PETER Hain, the former Young Liberal has become the foremost theoretician of the 'cuddly left' (whatever that may be). This is a thoughtful book with arguments that deserve consideration, highly revealing for many of its stated and unstated assumptions reveal the limits to Hain's radicalism.
After explaining how the present British electoral system is unfair, Hain argues that none of the various systems of proportional representation on offer is more democratic. Instead he favours the non-proportional 'alternative vote' (AV) which, he argues would remedy some of the worst defects of the Westminster system whilst retaining many of its virtues (such as the constituency system).
So what is wrong with PR? First, all conceivable systems would mean that MPs would either have no constituency or would represent vastly enlarged ones, this would reduce the opportunities that local people have to influence a parliamentary representative, would greatly weaken local political organisation, and the accountability of MPs to the electorate and to local parties would be undermined This would be worst under national list system which might invest all power in the central party bureaucracies.
Secondly, any notion of the electorate being able to choose between clearly defined party platforms would be abandoned in favour of wheeling and dealing behind the scenes after an election to produce a coalition government based on policies that nobody voted for. Such a system might distribute seats in proportion to votes but power might rest in the hands of small and unpopular centre parties.
Hain also suggests, using a series of comparisons with other countries, that PR might not bring the stability in for. He ment that the Alliance hopes further argues, against supporters of PR on the lett, that PR would not necessarily increase the numbers of womer and black people in the House of Commons and that small parties, like the Greens and the Communist Party, would tail to secure representation under the single transferable vote (STV) system they both 30 favour.
Hain concludes by making some familiar - but nonetheless important criticisms of the British constitution. He calls for a much greater decentralisation of effective power, a sort of 'Americanisation' of the central state involving more resources for MPs and parliamentary approval of top public appointments, and structures to encourage more popular participation in government at all levels. Finally he recommends introducing the alternative vote system for parliamentary elections the system would resemble an eliminating ballot system of election whereby voters placed candidates in order of preference with the losers being eliminated and their votes distributed until a winner emerged having over 50 per cent of vote). This would have the advantage that an MP would need majority support within a constituency and yet would retain the element of accountability and local representation that presently exists
There are many possible responses to Hain's arguments. Perhaps it is untortunate, given his stress on local accountability and his dislike of national party bureaucracies, that his book appeared in the run-up to the Knowsley North by-election. However, the solution that he finally plumps for — AV - must be untenable. As he himself admits, it would probably have the same effects as PR on the formation of governments, in which case all that he says about the electorate choosing between rival manifestos would go out of the window.
Secondly, Hain fails to consider the homogenising effect that AV would have on party representation in the Commons. In most constituencies the result would depend on the transfers of Alliance voters who would probably plump for the Tory or Labour candidate who was closest to their own views. Even if this did not in fact happen (and Alliance supporters instead transferred their votes fairly across the country) the suspicion is that it would cause many parties to select a 'safe. candidate. Instead of a House of Commons containing every shade of opinion from Jeremy Corbyn to Harvey Proctor, most MPs would be clones of either Roy Hattersley or Kenneth Baker.
The real problem with Hain's book emerges when he discusses the possibility that PR would lead to presentation of black people in parliament? 'Is the argument that we need to move towards a system of "functional representation" of political interests?',
'This would short-circuit the idea of "general" representation, which seeks to aggregate various interests under a common programme political priorities can be ordered coherently in relation to each otherf rather than left to the vagaries interest-group bargaining and special pleading'
Hain's pejorative reference to the 'vagaries of interest-group bargaining' serves to camouflage the fact that his idea of 'general' representation is a nonsense — a liberal-democratic fairy story. It is quite impossible for someone to represent me in all circumstances and for all purposes rather than for some welldefined purpose. That is not to say that the principle of territorial representation that Hain argues for is invalid, but it must be complemented by other types of representation of people as producers, as women and so on. Such a system, coupled with the right of electors to recall and dismiss their representative, would form the basis for a genuine system of participatory democracy. This much should be common ground between reformist and revolutionary socialists, and it is a measure of how far social-democratic thought has fallen since the time of, for example, guild socialism, that Hain finds himself imprisoned by such liberal shibboleths.
INTERNATIONAI. No7 November/December 1986
international REVIEWS
Christmas crackers
THE CHRISTMAS season may be a bourgeois hype, but there's no getting round it — guilt or gifts, it's your choice! Books have been c avourite recourse tor lettist jitt-givers ever since Marx':
hildren presented their dad with c specially-bound edition of not-so-Dickensian Chrismas long ago. To help its readers through the traditionally desperate last-minute search for appropriate presents for comrades and friends, International offers the following suggestions. A good read remains the best antidote to the (transitional?) demands of the holiday season. Trotsky, David King, Basil Blackwell, £19.50. OK so it's pricey, but David King's oictorial biography of that notorious Russian trouble-maker (previewed exclusively in our last issue) is our recommended Christmas gift for that special someone! With an introduction by Tamara Deutscher and an excellent commentary by James Ryan, this magnificent 340 page book assembles the largest photographic record of Trotsky's life yet. For those with a sense of history... and of graphic design. Scarlet Song, Mariamma Ba, Longman African Classics, £2.95 (paperback). The last work of the late author, now translated from the French, portrays one woman's struggle with tradition and chauvinism in Senegal. Proof that the novel is alive and well - at least in Africa! The Chaneysville Incident, David Bradley, Serpent's Tail, £5.95 (paperback). Highly-praised in the States, this novel tells the story of a Black history professor's investigation into his father's mysterious death — a quest which precipitates an exploration of his enslaved ancestors with surprising results. Prisoners of the American Dream, Mike Davis, Verso, £7.95 (paperback). Not an easy read, but a landmark in the historiography of the American working-class and its search for an NTERNATIONAL No 7 November/December 1986 independent politics. If you want to required reading.
Virağo Modern Classics
Their Eyes Were Watching God, Zora Neale Hurston, Virago, £3.95. Reprint of classic 1937 novel by Black recently rediscovered by Walker, Morison, Angelou, et al.
know the whys and hows of Reaganism and the answer to the vexed question of
American exceptionalism, then Davis is
Zora Neale Hurston
Their Eyes Were Watching God
(paperback).
America's premiere woman story-teller, socialist.
Hungarian Tragedy, Peter Fryer, New Park, £2.95 (paperback). Fryer was Morning Star correspondent in Budapest during the 1956 uprising and subsequent Soviet repression. His brilliantly written, first-hand account of the events — reprinted on their thirtieth anniversary — split the British CP. Zeynep: That Really Happened To Me, Zeynep Hasbudak and Brian Simons, ALTARF, £2.50 Nine-year-old's account of life in Hackney and her fight against deportation to Turkey — a fight which she finally lost. Excellent campaigning book for children. Solik, Life in the Soviet Union 1939-1946, by KS Karol, Pluto, £7.95, (paperback). Autobiographical account of young Pole's extraordinary adventures during World War Two. Escape from the Nazis to the Soviets led to arrest by the NKVD, subsequent escape, enlistment in Soviet airforce, promotion to rank of Junior Commissar in the Caucasus, a second arrest and unexpected release. Exciting, readable, sympathetic account of the Soviet people by an anti-Stalinist
Cricket, CLR James, Allison and
Busby, £14.95 (hardback).
Nearly forty years of cricket correspondence, journalism, history and analysis, from the greatest of the small band of Marxist cricketing cogitators.
Ideal gift for the leftish sports nut.
Where Sixpence Lives, Norma
Kitson, Chatto and Windus, £9.95.
(Hardback).
Finely-written autobiography: from
Durban childhood through years of bitter struggle with the apartheid state to recent conflicts with London-based ANC bureaucracy.
A Long Way Home, Claude
MacKay, Liberation Classics, Pluto,
£4.95 (paperback).
First published in 1937, this autobiography of the Jamaican-born poet and novelist spans his years as a
¡leading tigure of the Harlem
Renaissance and his off-and-on involvement in left politics. Features his trips through between-the-wars Britain,
France, Soviet Union, and Africa, as well as encounters with Shaw, Wells,
DuBois, Trotsky, Chaplin, and others.
ERNEST MANDEL
THE MEANING OF THE
SECOND WORLD WAR
The Meaning of the Second World
War, by Ernest Mandel, Verso,
£6.95 (paperback).
Synoptic, readable account of the global clash — a war of conflicts within conflicts within conflicts - whose outcome is the world we live in.
Error of Judgement: The Truth About the Birmingham Bombings, by Chris
Mullin, Chatto and Windus, €10.95
(hardback).
The story of the casual victims of mid-seventies anti-Irish hysteria who are
32 still seeking justice.
Book-burners delight — or Danish fashion show. See Jenny lives with ... Black American Politics, from the Washington Marches to Jesse Jackson, Manning Marable, Verso, £6.95 (paperback). Fine-grained historical study by as well as long-range analysis, with a fascinating and well-balanced account of the Jackson campaign and the strengths and weaknesses of the 'Rainbow Coalition'. Dvorak in Love, Josef Skvorecky, Chatto and Windus, £10.95 (hardback). latest warm and witty fiction with less enthusiasm than his previous efforts. Perhaps the change in scenery from Stalinised central Europe to racist turn-of-the-century USA had something to do with this. A tantastic yet deeply researched historical novel tracing, between the Czech composer and the
(paperback). independent Marxist. Excellent on detail heated waters. (paperback). Bourgeois reviewers greeted Skvorecky's among other things, the surprising links development of Black American music.
Four Novels: The Getaway, The Killer Inside Me, The Grifters, Pop. 1280, Jim Thompson, Black Box Thrillers, Zomba Books, £5.95 Deranged, psychopathic prose from a master of the American thriller. Not for the ideologically squeamish. She Came Too Late, Mary Wings, Women's Press, £3.95 (paperback). Original piece of crime fiction with lesbian heroine whose work on 'Women's Hotline' leads her into very Jenny Lives With Eric and Martin, Gay Men's Press, £2.95 The book-burner's delight! Buy now before it becomes a collector's item! Photo-montage of late seventies Denmark (complete with flares). This list was selected by CAROLINE RAULT and DAVE PALMER of Reading Matters Bookshop, 10 Lymington Ave., London N22 and MIKE MARQUSEE, author of the recently-published thriller, Slow Turn (Michael Joseph, £9.95).
INTERNATIONAL No 7 November/December 1986