Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

The struggle for health

· International no. 5, July–August 1986 · pp 32-33 · 1,010 words

The struggle for health

PAUL STERN David Sanders with Richard Carver, Medicine and the Politics of Underdevelopment, Macmillan 1985 £2.95 (paperback); £12.00 (hardback). I READ David Sanders' book with great pleasure. This is no ordinary text on the problems of the suffering third world, but is about the nature of health care in a social political world having been the victim of colonialism and imperialism. The underdeveloped world is underdeveloped not just from accident of history, but because of the growth of international capital and the ravages of western industrialisation.

He describes the development of the health services in Britain, linking social advancement to the struggles of working people. For the masses living in dire circumstances in the slums around industrial conurbations, the prime health needs were for clean water, hygienic sewage disposal and adequate nutrition. Improvements in health followed the struggle for workers' rights generally, due to the growth of the Labour Party and trades unions, many of which started as triendly societies tor the protection of their members' health. The tactors which made this possible were the agricultural and industrial revolutions, which increased the production of food and commodities and forced workers to organise to protect and defend their interests. For most people the contribution of specific medical advances has been relatively minor.

The book is filled with beautiful graphs, and informative tables. Death rates from infectious diseases - the major killer of infants and children - fell impressively from 1860 to 1925, some 20 years before effective anti-infectious drugs became widely available

The practice of medicine developed with the growth of modern capitalism, 'doctoring' being the possession of gifted individuals, shrouded in mystique and not communicable to others who were not part of the magic circle. The art and not much science of healing was available only to those who could pay. In reality, for most people the contribution of specific medical advances hasbeen relatively minor.

The same analysis applies to the underdeveloped world. By and large the problems that cause early death and high illness rates are the same problems that afflicted the developed world. Poor nutritional status and low resistance to disease are the root causes of high death rates especially among the young in the 30 underdeveloped world. Many of these

Mother trained to nurse her own children in Mozambique are aggravated by colonialism and imperialism.

Some specific diseases were introduced to which indigenous popula. tions had no natural immunity; smallpox, measles and typhus. However, the greed of imperialism for raw materials and cheap labour ensured the continued depression of living standards, and often aggravated precarious supplies of food from subsistence economies to starvation where cash-crops replaced staple foods.

Imported with the economic and political effects of colonialism went the dominant ideology; the position of western technology and the ned to 'curé' patients rather than to prevent disease Like the 'inverse care law' in the developed world - where there is the greatest need there are the fewest facilities — so too the 'three-quarters rule' in underdeveloped countries. Three-quarters of the population live in rural areas, yet three-quarters of the spending on medical care is in urban areas where three-quarters of the doctors (and other health workers) live. Three-quarters of the deaths are due to conditions that can be prevented at low cost, yet three-quarters of the medical budget is spent on curative services, many of them at high cost. Ihe colonizers initiated medical care in their own image; doctors prefer to work from 'disease palaces' rather than help serve people at a local rural level.

Sanders discusses the role of multinational drug companies in the distortion of health care, big business, private medical care, and how these affect the nature of services provided in both developed and underdeveloped countries. A critical review of different kinds of health care, such as that provided in China and Cuba, the nature of 'bare-foot doctoring' and Mao's shrewd observation that changing doctors' views of themselves (working and living in the countryside) would help them to become better doctors serving the needs of the people. The real advances contributed by the Chinese experience lies in its ability to eradicate large public health problems by mass actions - the burying of snails to eliminate bilarzia is one example.

Sanders is an advocate of the Village Health Worker concept which has emerged in many underdeveloped countries. This is an attempt to tailor the delivery of health care appropriate to and under the control of the local community served by the VHW. The VHW differs from the 'auxiliary' in several fundamental respects: S/he should be selected by the people themselves, and responsible to them; should be part-time and therefore subsist by working in the community perhaps with a subsidy trom the local community or the national health service; and may be someone who has already been a 'traditional' healer and trained in the community in health education and preventive measures.

In Zimbabwe, after a long struggle for liberation, a scheme to train VHW was established at Bondolfi Mission. This was initiated by the local villagers themselves, and this reviewer has as one of his warmest memories the recollection of witnessing the first graduation of some 200 VHW at a ceremony in Bondolfi. Over five hours the recipients and audience applauded and shouted slogans as each VHW received her certificate, many with babies strapped to their backs!

There is a need for 'curative' services and appropriate technology in the underdeveloped world; the issue is who decides and by which criteria. Sanders suggests that this has to be decided by the community served by the health worker: 30 'But, most ditticult of all, the concerned health worker must be a servant to the people even when they are mistaken ir Society will only be transformed and ill health combatted when people are tree to make their own mistakes.

An excellent book, relating the development of health care to the underlying political and economic forces of international capitalism. I enthusiastically recommend it.

nternationa! REVIEWS

← From Resistance to Rebellion · Harold Wilson's ghost →

Something wrong on this page?