Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Wapping Assault

· International no. 4, May–June 1986 · p 28 · 1,102 words

Trade unions Britain Labour Party

Wapping assault

As we go to press the printworkers continue to fight for their jobs. DAVID JONES looks at the negative consequences of the print union leaders' "sweet reasonableness" in their conduct of the strike. MAY DAY demonstrations, organised to support the sacked printworkers, erupted into violence as the police ran riot at Wapping. Even the normally cautious Brenda Dean was heard to denounce the police for their vicious attacks on the pickets, their families and supporters. Yet despite the genuine outrage voiced be Dean, the print unions were back in court that very week to purge their contempt. This act was almost symbolic of the 'softly-softly' approach adopted by the print union leaderships in the vain hope that this would curry favour with public opinion'. It is precisely this approach which sees the print unions staring defeat in the face.

The possibility of such a defeat would have been inconceivable five years ago. The mighty print unions seemed impregnable, with massive financial reserves and the strength to force the Fleet Street managements to accept high wages and restrictive practices. Yet now they seem about to allow a multinational media baron to chuck them unceremoniously out of 5000 jobs and recognition rights on key daily and Sunday titles, in return for miserly compensation and a worthless, uneconomic printing plant.

This sorry state of affairs is another blow to the labour movement as a whole, still reeling from the defeat of the miners. Whatever brave face may be put on the eventual deal' with Murdoch, it will be a major defeat. It is clear that the bottom line for Murdoch is refusal to grant recognition rights to the NGA & SOGAT in the Wapping plant or to take back any of the militant workforce that have been sacked. The result has already been felt throughout Fleet Street with each management in turn imposing drastic cuts in the workforce, the introduction of new technology and an end to traditional work practices. Each workforce has felt powerless to oppose their employer, fearing that walking out on strike would mean walking out for ever.

The carrot dangled in front of the print union leaderships is the 'gift' of the Grays Inn Road printing plant to start their own paper. But without massive investment or subsidy, such as News International could provide if it so wished, any labour movement paper produced from the plant, especially one born from such inauspicious conditions, would be bound to falter. The union management would end up sacking its own members and the whole idea of a labour movement paper be discredited in the process.

Needless to say the most keen on the idea of the union selling out their members in return for the plant has been the Labour leadership. Kinnock's office immediately issued a statement cautiously welcoming the idea, when even TUC chief Norman Willis bad attacked the notion. Such an approach is entirely consistent with the Labour leadership's support' for the print unions over Wapping. This has been as unstinting and inspiring as the support' given to the miners strike. Labour has a sorry record on the media. Instead of campaigning for its stated policy of breaking up the media monopolies, the Labour leadership kept silent when Robert Maxwell launched his bid for the Mirror. A press statement trom Kinnock's office attacking the bid was abandoned after pressure from Hattersley and a 'phone call from Maxwell. Maxwell has returned the favour by vicious campaigns against the party s left wing, and of course numerous sackings, lockouts and threats against his workforce.

The Labour Party's wretched role in the Wapping dispute was not entirely unexpected, nor was the capitulation of the TUC. Faced with the open connivance of the EETPU leadership in Murdoch's union-bursting operation the only serious defence of the union movement would have been to expel the EETPU from the TUC, and if necessary organise those loyal to the TUC into a new affiliated union. There is evi. dence that the EETPU leaders were not fully prepared for expulsion from the TUC, fearing a revolt in their own ranks and a damaging split with their other right wing allies in the TUC. It is possible that such a move would have influenced the balloting in the AUEW elections against the right's candidate Bill Jordan, possibly further isolating the EETPU in the labour movement. But the principle of unity of the union apparatuses was placed above the principle of basic union solidarity in struggle, aud the EETPU has been given further breathing space to foster business unionism within the TUC.

More disappointing has been the pathetic response of the print union leaderships to the dispute. Years of inter-union bickering and job poaching had weakened the potential for a united response to the Murdoch gauntlet. His heavy-handed style of threats and sackings was a public relations gift to the print unions, whose public image was somewhat tarnished by the legendary wages and conditions on Fleet Street. Yet their obsession for staying within the law and sweet reasonableness resulted in the central tactic of a boycott of Murdoch titles. This has been a complete failure, with some titles actually registering an increase in sales since the dispute began. Alternative approaches of encouraging broad labour movement mass pickets, or drawing in the test of Fleet Street have been dismissed and discouraged. No one would pretend that the latter course of action would have been easy given the climate of fear amongst other Fleet Street workers. But a determined campaign for escalating solidarity action from the union leaderships would have generated much greater confidence than the empty calls to stop reading The Sun.

Now another traditional bastion of the trade union movement stands on the verge of defeat, as a ruthless employer threatens it with naked class warfare. Union leaders will no doubt conclude that even greater capitulation to the employers is the only answer. Others in the labour movement will draw the opposite conclusion and begin to organise within the unions for an equally ruthless class response against the employers. Meanwhile with the print unions weakened we can look forward to our daily newspaper diet being served up by ever fewer and more powerful press barons freed from any pressure from their workforce over media standards and impartiality. We can expect more Gotcha's, Mein Fuhrer's and Thrilled to Blitz's and more anti-union press crusades. We must make sure that any future Labour government not only repeals the Tories anti-union laws which have been used against the print unions, but alsotakes radical measures to reform the media itself.

INTERNATIONAL No. 4. Maylune 1986

← Tribute to Simone De Beauvoir · Marxism Today's 'New axis' →

Something wrong on this page?