Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Child abuse — crisis in the family?

· International no. 2, January–February 1986 · pp 32-33 · 1,375 words

Women Racism and anti-fascism

No oNE dAN read the horrific reports of child abuse and murder splashed over the front pages this last year without feeling shock and revulsion. Young children bitten, beaten, starved, knifed and raped, usually by their father, must surely make us ask what is hap- pening and how it can be prevented.

The right wing media has its own answers Child killers are 'evil monsters'. Coupled to this, and clearly shown in the tragic cases of Tyra Henry and Jasmine Beckford, is overt racism — implying all black men are poten- tial child abusers. The media are keen to mention illegitimacy rates and 'live-in' boyfriends, concluding that child abuse is a result of the collapse of familiy life. The right wing answer therefore is a return to a loving, preferably white, nuclear family, coupled with increased law and order, longer prison sentences and minimal social services. There is also a clear attack on local councils with progressive child care policy and often, at the time of media attention, involved in the rate capping struggle.

Especially picked out for blame are local government social workers, NALGO mem- bers in the forefront in the struggle against public sector cuts. Some Labour councils such as Lambeth fell for this divisive tactic. Brent NALGO members are currently at- tempting to get reinstatement of workers sacked in the aftermath of the Jasmine Beckford inquiry.

Yet the left has remained alarmingly quiet on the problem of child abuse. It avoids con- demning what must be, like wife battering, a social crime. The left's only public statement on the subject is to blame the huge increase in unemployment and cuts in social services. But is this the whole story?

Let's start by looking at some of the limited facts available about what we would now call child abuse. It is certainly not a new phenomenon and existed long before the rise of capitalism. Early history documents child slavery prostitution, and infanticide (par- ticularly favoured by British royals). Girls faced special mutilations such as foot bin- ding, and infibulation is still practised today. The heyday of the British Empire with its Victorian values, saw appalling atrocities in-

forced labour, flicted on children workhouses and brutal corporal punishment, doled out by family, church, and state. In 1870 according to official records, 202 children died from manslaughter, 113 from neglect. Children of the wealthy didn't escape flogging and fagging were part of public school discipline for boys, educational and sexual deprivation for girls. The 'golden age' gave rise to charities such as the Na- tional Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children (NSPCC).

But apart from a few social reformers and charitable institutions, the problems were left well alone until the tragic death of Maria Caldwell in 1974. The press ran their own trial on the family and social worker and established a pattern for future reporting. The enquiry that followed led to the establishment of registers, kept by the NSPCC, of all children known or suspected of being abused, and specialist NSPCC units to treat abused children and their families.

In 1984 the NSPCC had over 7000 cases

Child abust Crisis in

the

family:

LAS

ARER

EILEEN

STA

RED

strike

threat by union

on its register, with 600 cases of serious in- jury and 59 children dead. The statistical trends from the 70's indicate an alarming in- crease in moderate child abuse, while serious and fatal cases seem to be on the decrease, in spite of the press hysteria. The debate rages in professional circles about just what all this data means, but what is clear is that many children in Britain are at scrious risk from violence, and with increases in detection and the social crisis, the numbers will increase. The data show a significant correlation bet- ween increasing unemployment and increas- ing child abuse. This raises the thorny ques- tion of are we seeing 'lumpenisation' of a small percentage of the working class as a result of the economic and social crisis? Full employment, for men and women, would obviously drastically improve conditions for parents and children and start to relieve the grinding despair that millions now feel.

However, the wealthy also abuse their children, but usually avoid detection and the courts, as American studies have shown. And of course, the rich can buy their way out of the pressures that can result in child abuse - good housing, active social life and most importantly a nanny for 24 hour child-care.

What is strikingly clear from statistics and from the work of feminists is that the biological family is not a particularly safe place for women or children to live. 'Scream quietly or the neighbours may hear' the bat- tering, rape, incest — the horrors committed against women and children in the name of marital or parental rights. The left can't just turn to Marxist economics, we must look to the oppressive nature of the nuclear family to understand the socialist policy and practice needed to start to prevent child abuse.

In today's society children are privatised, they are the private property of their parents. There is an appalling lack of collec- tive responsibility for children in Britain, with the majority of socialists be ng no better than the establishment - just look at the

lack of childcare at political events. And of course the private daily responsibility for children falls on women, the strain can be unbearable. Feminists have long demanded free, quality 24 hour child care as one of the prerequisites for women's liberation and socialism.

Not surprisingly, child abuse experts find that baby sitting circles, playgroups, and 'crisis' nurseries are central to the rehabilita- tion and prevention of abuse in high risk families. But few experts draw the conclu- sions of the need for more and better child care for all.

Monetarism is out to destroy what little childcare there is and we end up defending services which even in their heyday were racist and inadequate in many ways. Some left councils have attempted to extend

childcare and equally importantly tried to

provide services geared to the needs of children and the vast majority of parents, who do not fit into the white, heterosexist two parent model. But even the most pro- gressive authorities have a policy of keeping families together. Again another difficult area for feminists: we know theoretically that the family is not defensible, but without women's economic independence, without reproductive rights, without socialisation of domestic production and reproduction, without an end to discrimination, what do we do? And we need to understand how racism and imperialism affects black families resulting in black women raising many addi- tional and sometimes different demands to those of white feminists.

The recommendations from the Jasmine Beckford enquiry also challenge 'family is best' , but of course it does not propose the finances and equalities to enable an alter- native to the family; it however suggests some working class families are not fit and substitute (read white, nuclear) families will do a better job. This report will have a big impact, bringing with it more profes- sionalisation, more management social ser- vices and reinforces the concept of the unfit working class family, which will be used, I suspect, particularly against black families and extended into the arena of deportation and immigration policy.

Another theme taken up in the report and again important for us to develop as socialists is the rights of children. Children are seen as parents' private property and therefore parents can do what they like to children. There is also still the assumption that children must somehow be dominated, including by use of physical punishment, to maintain discipline and teach them how to behave. Hand in hand with this 'breaking the spirit' is the assumption that children haven't minds of their own, hence disbelief when girls reveal incest, ridicule when children take up racism in schools.

Clearly then, child abuse poses many questions for socialists and feminists which we can't simply reduce to economic arguments, crucially important though they are. We need to develop our understanding of the family, including the effects of racism and imperialism on the family in order to struggle for the policy and practice needed to end child abuse.

Januar

international

REVIEWS

To

← The strategy of the ANC · To Russia with love →

Something wrong on this page?