Solomon Mahlangu, ANC Fighter, executed by the apartheid state.
TE
Hector Peterson, aged I3, the first to die in the Soweto uprising
Bishop Desmond Tutu, spokesperson for the
United Democratic Front international, No. I. November/December |985
Slander!
CHARLIE VAN GELDEREN THERE can be no dispute about the fact that the African National Congress (AN) is today the most important organisation in the liberation struggle in South Africa. But the impression which one gathers from the media coverage of the turbulent events in South Africa is that it is the only organisation engaged in the fight against the apartheid regime. This is far from being the case.
Undoubtedly the great mass of the people fighting the repressive apparatus of the state in the townships identify with the ANC and especially with its imprisoned leader, Nelson Mandela. But the ANC itself, and its close ally the South African Communist Party (SACP), are fully aware that it has to win the hegemony of the struggle in ideological battle with other tendencies, especially the National Forum (NF), the Azanian Peoples Organisation (Azapo) and the community organisations. These have sprung up spontaneously in the townships and, in practice, give a daily lead to the resistance movement which often has its immediate origins in opposition to increased rents, fuel charges, transport costs, etc.
Both Secheba, the official organ of the ANC, and African Communist, the quarterly journal of the SACP, have been carrying on an "ideological' battle against Black Consciousness (BC), the National Forum and Azapo. If these organisations were without influence one can be sure that these journals would not be wasting so much space in refuting their views.
The AN and SACP have also been casting wary eyes on the growth of the independent trade union movement in South Arica. The leaderships of these unions, which were born out of the strikes in Durban and the Rand in the 1970s, have generally come from outside the AN and SACP, or the ANC-affiliated South African Congress of Trade Unions (Sactu), which was never banned, having gone into voluntary exile alongside the banned AN and CP in the 1960s.
The thirty six main independent unions are set on a course which will lead to the launching of a 'super-federation' at the end of Novemebr. While cautiously welcoming this move toward trade union unity in words, the ANC, and more especially the SACP leadership have some misgivings. They fear that this powerful movement of the organised working class could generate a pole of attraction outside their control and so diminish their influence in the resistance movement.
The campaign to denigrate the independet trade union leadership took off in 1983 with an attack by "Toussaint" (South African Communist No. 93) on the address of Joe Foster, General Secretary of the
Federation of South African Trade Unions (FOSATU) at that organisation's 1982 Conference. "Toussaint' tried to show, with the help of liberal quotations from Lenin torn out of context, that Foster's approach is "workerist', that he wants to substitute the trade unions for the political organisations of the working class. In fact, the whole tenor of Foster's address, as the following quotation shows, is just the opposite:
*..worker activities such as strikes and protests do not in themselves mean that a working class movement or working class politics exist. These later are more than that.
"Toussaint's attacks have been followed by others in African Communist and Secheba but it reaches a new low in the most recent issue of the SACP quarterly, African Communist No. 103 (Fourth Quarter 1985 pp9-10). This time the assault comes in the Editorial Notes and it tries to establish a link between the growing effectiveness of the trade unions with the ruling class 'reforms' - and this on the very eve of the unification conference?
Resorting the well-tried Stalinist method of the 'amalgam' (mixing up two unrelated sets of fact and drawing false conclusions from them), the Notes refer to an appeal by a 'verligte Professor Blackie Swart of Stallenbosch University to employers and the government not to use strong arm tactics against independent trade unions because this could have disastrous long-term consequences and could lead to unmanageable industrial unrest .. which will result in a shift towards more politically motivated organisations...
In other words,' write our SACP hacks, 'he is appealing to the bosses to let the unions succeed in negotiations for higher wages and better conditions because failure at the negotiating table would throw the workers into the arms of the AN and SACP: And now comes the amalgam: "This explains why so many employers recognised the relevant trade union and allowed it to function. This explains why millions of rand are being channelled by the CIFTU, AFLCIO and other bodies towards South African unions which it is hoped will develop into a "third force" drawing workers away from the ANC. So according to the CP, the bosses are supporting the unions inorder to win support away from the ANC!
This does not explain, of course, the fierce struggles of the unions for recognition nor does it explain, as stated in the ANC journal Secheba (March, 1985 p. 21) the arrest of 'over a thousand trade unionists' under the emergency regulations. These slanderous remarks in African Communist can only serve to undermine the strength and influence of the trade unions and the vital part which the organised working class will have to play if South Africa is to achieve freedom.