FEATURES
TORIES OUT
BRIDGWATER ANTI-POLL TAX UNION
BETTER TO BREAK THE LAW
Poll tax activism remains strong: but only a minority of non-payers are involved
they are completely in favour of fixed ex- hange rates and membership of the ERM as a "mechanism for tackling inflation".
Clearly they believe that the rate of ster- ling at the point of entry is crucial. But they are apparently less concerned with a competi- tive rate (ic a low rate) than with stability at whatever rate is set. A low rate would have the effect of reducing the trade deficit and making British firms more competitive. But it would also have the effect of making imports more expensive, further increasing inflation, and therefore reducing living standards for workers in Britain.
Key participants in the Policy Review process have argued that membership of the ERM would be a useful brake on any tenden- cy towards a run on sterling following the election of a Labour govemment.
It is clear that, despite the limitation on domestic policies that would be imposed by membership of the ERM, Kinnock and his co- thinkers are prepared to give up control of, and therefore responsibility for, Labour's policies. Harsh anti-inflationary measures with inevitable attacks on workers' living standards will be defended on the basis that the Labour government no longer controls the instruments necessary to run the economy any other way.
Labour is already paving the way for all this by talking tough on pay and the unions.
Shadow Chancellor John Smith, has warned that in the new Europe, British workers must be careful not to price themsel ves out of the competition. To make sure his message is received, understood and obeyed, most of the central Tory trade union measures will be kept on the statute book. The point will be hammered home further at Labour's own conference in October.
To make sure all this happens, and smoothly, Labour's leaders have prepared the ground carefully.
Determined to avoid the scenes of the seventies when the trade unions brought their apposition to the Labour govemment's wage controls right into the Labour Party, Kinnock is proposing that a weaker conference, with looser ties to the working class, would have less say in drawing up policy. The members, without the means of influencing policy. simply wouldn't matter.
If Kinnock's proposed organisational overhaul gets the go-ahead, we will witness sweeping changes on a scale not yet seen, and the death of what little democracy already ex- ists in the Labour Party. Policy changes have come and gone in the past. But these reforms will make sure policy is made from the top, is passed through the movement as required, and doesn't go have to face any unseemly political challenges.
Crawling up quietly behind Thatcher, and winning the next election by default seems to be as high as Kinnock's sights are set.
by Roland Wood
Many councils in England and Wales are well into the process of Court action to obtain Liability Orders against those who haven't paid the Poll Tax.
The number of summonses issued repre- sents a very significant level of mass non-pay- ment - a combination of those who simply can't pay (the majority) and those who can but have stood in solidarity with the poorest layers of the working class.
The Courts have provided an important focus for an anti-poll tax movement that was, since the end of March, fast losing momen- tum. Once again new people have become politically active for the first time. Local anti- poll tax groups have been strengthened and broadened beyond the limited base of the or- ganised left.
At each new stage in the struggle more people will get involved; but many will have
been intimidated into paying. If the mass character of the movement is to be maintained we must continually fight for collective solidarity
The Court cases have also highlighted I many of the problems within the anti-poll tax movement.
Militant tells us that "We are winning!" The Socialist Workers Party proclaim that "Court cases make the difference!" But are we, and do they? Yes and no: but more no than yes.
The struggle around the Courts has
around
provided victories of one kind or another. In some very diverse areas there have been rela- tively large and important mobilisations and demonstrations. Overall, one in ten of those who have been summonsed have tumed up to Court. But how can this new level of par- ticipation be sustained?
Militant and the SWP overestimate the strength and solidity of the movement, at- tempting to show a mass movement that is on the offensive when it is actually on the defen- sive. We are defending people in Court; we are defending people against the possible use of bailiffs ... Of course as socialists we are for the defence of the independent interests of the working class and defence of working class living standards; so what is the problem?
The problem is this: The movement's aim is to defeat the poll tax; many would also like if possible to bring Thatcher down with it - but neither the Militant or the SWP are build- ing any bridge to link the current stage of the movement with the fulfillment of that aim, any strategy that will genuinely take the movement onto the offensive.
This confusion has been reflected, certain- ly in the case of Militant, in the generalised approach that they have argued the movement should have to the Courts. If we are winning" generally, then are we winning in the Courts. Again, yes and no. Where 'victories" have oc- curred (eg. adjournments) it has been largely due to the physical presence of hundreds of non-payers turning up at Court for a hearing.
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 27, October 1990
Page 9
John Harris
(NUJ)
FEATURES
This has been the major factor in blocking to compromise on this specific issue. In Court proceedings and preventing (for the mo- order to force this limited concession it was ment) Liability Orders being granted against necessary to play by bourgeois rules in, what hundreds of people - thus giving breathing is after all, a bourgeois game. space to consolidate the movement and
But this is where the concessions stop. develop further mobilisation. But to argue, as Reference to the conduct and status of the Militant supporters have done, that in a show- Mackenzie in the rest of the 1970 ruling is down between some vague notion of more open to different legal interpretation. proletarian justice and the reality of bourgeois law 'we will win", does
a disservice to the movement.
The aim of the magistrates, on behalf of the local council, is to grant Liability Or-
wish to appear as inde- Don't pay
ders against people who have not paid the poll tax. They may
pendent "arbitrators", but as an arm of the bourgeois state they are not neutral. Arbitration
it collect
does not take place in a vacuum; it takes place within the existing framework of society. and in this case the framework of bour- geois law - including the poll tax.
Of course, conces- sions will sometimes be made by arbitrators; usually this depends upon the balance of forces. But the basic aim of arbitration is to
maintain the status quo as such, if necessary by compromising a bit on secondary questions.
Arguments that
have been taking place in many courts over the
use of "Mackenzie's friends" are a useful il- lustration. The legal precedent for the right of each Respondent (the non-payer) to have advice from a "friend" on how to deal with the procedures of the Court
ions as well as in the community is now vital The magistrate's ruling on interpretation will
and what type of questions to ask the Council Officer is set out in a 1970 Court of Appeal ruling. This ruling was consequently incor- porated into Stones, the procedural bible for Civil Courts. Non-payment of the Poll Tax is a
always have more authority than the opinion of either the "Mackenzie" or the Respondent.
Moreover, concessions can of course be taken away, or indeed refused. If a consistent
mobilisation of non-payers is successful — two civil matter.
or more Courts may well be used. This is now
Consequently, the right of each Respon- the case in Sutton, with the right to a Macken-
dent to have a 'Mackenzie' ought to be an ad- zie recognised in one Court but not in the
mitted fact. In Sutton, a summarised account other. Many Courts have never allowed the of the original ruling was read out by one of use of Mackenzies. the Respondents forcing the Court to agree -
Further to this, the Courts will use their
Page 10
authority to limit the potential for dragging cases out for as long as is possible by insisting upon strict adherence to Court procedures. Short of having sympathetic lawyers constant- ly on tap, the decisions of the Court are much harder to challenge successfully. The Courts are changing their tactics from week to week, using their authority to make the rules up as
they go along. Time-wasting
has only really been success-
ful when one or two of the
Respondents are eloquent,
confident and well briefed
enough to just keeping going.
Unless the Court has pre-
viously decided that it will sit
right into the evening until all
cases have been dealt with
then adjoumments will be
given.
But adjoumments are only
partial victories. Liability Or-
ders have been prevented, but
only in the short term. The
real victory is the rise in the
numbers, and the level of confidence and militancy of those people who tum up at Court. The overwhelming majority leave the Court still committed to non-payment. More people are also seeing the links that can be made be- tween different areas and forms of struggle. This is a minority - but it is an impor- tant minority. The better or- ganised the anti-poll tax movement is - both inside and outside the Court - the
more this will be the case. Revolutionary socialists need to sustain, to the best of their ability, the confidence and militancy of those layers of
the working class that have shown a willingness to fight
back - regardless of who
John Hanis these victories will be lost.
wins the next election - or
Resistance around the
Courts is very uneven. In
some areas campaigns are at-
tempting to cope with Court
cases four or five times a
week. If a local campaign is
weak to the rendo can hi
Or
weak the problems of responding effectively to the levels of non-payment can multiply hor- rendously. No amount of triumphalist gloss can hide these facts.
Once again we return to the problems of
sustai
en! ton al many
sustaining the momentum of a mass move- ment: of organising previously unorganised layers of the working class. Certainly in Sut- ton and probably in other areas, many non- payers are not in unions - and of those that are many have not been active. They have little or
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 27, October 1990
no experience of organising with others.
Rather than begin to find ways of seriously tackling these problems, Militant would ap pear to prefer that we put all our eggs into one basket. Their disproportionate concentration upon defence against bailiffs, ignoring the fight for trade union action, could potentially leave many campaigns paralysed when the local Council opts for wage arrestment as the initial form of debt recovery.
"Mass non-payment will win!" Militant tells us; and they no doubt hope it will, be- cause it cuts out the more complex business of building a genuine line-up of forces across the workers' movement as a whole that can defeat the poll tax - but may also lay down roots for the emergence of an ongoing mass movement.
The movement at the moment is volatile. It is rooted in the working class more by in- evitability than by design (it was inevitable that the working class would be the hardest hit by the tax). Coping with the pressures and the contradictions of a mass movement of this kind, a movement organised around a single economic issue, is no easy task.
No one on the left has a monopoly of wis- dom on how to solve these problems let alone any real experience of a movement of this kind or of how to tackle the challenges that have been thrown up.
What is required is a unity of purpose; a unity between the different areas of struggle against the Poll Tax and an ability to integrate new experiences and struggles into the overall character of the movement.
The effects of capping, along side an emer- gent financial crisis in a number of previously "clean" councils underlines the necessity of a "twin-track" strategy of building mass non- payment action alongside the fight in the unions, especially the local government unions, for action around wage arrestment, non-collection and the cuts.
The target of the poll tax is to force cuts in jobs and services. Through the intermediary of compliant councils the Tories hope to pass the cost of non-payment on to the workforce, and through cuts in services, back on to the com- munity. The fight against the poll tax - as a defence of living standards and of democratic rights - will become inseparable from the fight against cuts.
This is the strategic thread to what we have been arguing for some time. The majority of the anti-poll tax movement exists on the out- side of the organised labour movement. The existence of over 14 million non-payers offers a lead to thos fighting for trade union action against the threat of wage arrestment and potentially, in the specific unions concerned, against the implementation of the tax and against cuts.
Mass non-payment will not win on its own. his does not mean that its importance should be underestimated. It is a form of direct political action that needs to be brought in to the very heart of the existing organisa- tions of the working class.