Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Whose right to choose?

· Socialist Outlook no. 25, June 1990 · p 23 · 964 words

Women

FEATURES

mittee. Despite being very vaguely worded

AB NO RETURI

A015

this would have provided a very necessary

YES BS

counter weight to the Government's in

L BACKSTREET

sidious clause concerning the 'welfare of

YES NO ABORTIONS the child' born as a result of DI or NRTa:

TO CHOI YE Statements by the Lord Chancellor and

other ministers that the crucial factors in a

child's welfare are the permanence' and

"stability" provided by the marriage of the

parents and the presence of a man in the

household will only provide more grist to

the mill of judicial prejudice and reaction

and serve to intimidate the few clinics that

provide a non-discriminatory service.

This setback, together with the failure of

the other Labour proposals to democratise

the SLA and broaden its composition mean

that the Bill's restrictive effect on lesbians'

and single women's access to DI and NRTs

has been increased and reinforced.

The true victors are the Tory realists,

who have shaped and guided this Bill from

the beginning. They understand that fer-

tility control is necessary for women's par-

ticipation in the workforce, a participation

which is increasingly important to the

British economy. However, they insist that

control should not be vested in the woman

herself. Abortion laws are therefore

bounded by concepts of foetal rights and

viability, and empower doctors rather then

women.

This current is the dominant force in the

Goverment, and counts Health Secretary Kenneth Clarke amongst its spokespersons. It is firmly wedded to the idea of scientific progress as both the inevitable, proud product of capitalism and the motor force of economic advance; and it is also particularly susceptible to the lobbying of the medical establishment.

The Tory realists have steered a careful course between the fundamentalists and the left, sometimes sailing closer to one or the other to the keep the central project afloat and intact. The underlying aims of allowing re- search and the provision of DI and NRTs within a strictly regulated and controlled framework, most importantly within the con- text of the nuclear family, and of reconciling the immediate needs of the economy with the long term needs of the capitalist system, has been achieved and even strengthened by the amendments.

It is important to stress that this chapter in the struggle for women's reproductive freedom is not yet closed. The Third Reading is yet to come, bringing the possibilities both of further liberalisation of the abortion law and of a reactionary backlash. The Code of Practice promulgated under the Bill will be drawn up shortly. This promises further dis- crimination and restrictions on access to DI and NRTs unless there is a considerable shift in the political climate. Such a shift will not be produced spontaneously; it must be fought for.

SCOTTISH TRADES UNION CONGRESS

Womens

* Advisory Committee Trade unionists will need to mobilise against further attacks on a woman's right to choose Whose right to

By Rebecca Flemming

The Embryology Bill has continued to be a political battlefield as it makes its stor- my way through Parliament. The for- tunes of the warring factions have ebbed and flowed over the last six months, but there is no doubt about who has emerged victorious.

It is not the fundamentalist right, who suf- fered ignominious defeat on abortion and embryo research at the end of April, their belief that life' begins at conception un- ceremoniously trampled underfoot. Attempts by 'genetic fascist Lady Saltoun and vociferous bigots Ann Winterton and David Wilshire to blatantly discriminate against cer- tain groups of women, legally label them as unfit mothers and second class citizens and to explicitly prohibit by legislation the creation of 'fatherless" children have been blocked in both the Lords and Commons Committees.

Conversely, this is no unmitigated triumph for the pro-choice forces. Whilst the rout of the anti-abortionists is not to be summarily dismissed, neither must the reality of the situa- tion be ignored. The reduction in the abortion time limit to 24 weeks is a material loss; the consensus around arguments of foetal viability was overwhelming. In this context, the champions of a women's right to choose are increasingly few and far between.

How far the new exceptions to 24 weeks and the removal of the threat of criminal sanc- tions from doctors who perform late abortions

will counteract this loss remains to be seen, and fought over. Undoubtedly, the possibility for doctors to carry out later abortions has been opened up. Whether they will or not, and how many women will be able to fight through the ideological pressure and decimated resources of the NHS to ask for one is still an open question. Regional and local variation in the provision of abortion facilities will certainly increase.

The defeat for the idea of a woman's right to choose may well run alongside increased access to abortion in practice.

Importantly, the "hostage to fortune' for abortion law contained in the 14 day limit on embryo research must not be overlooked. The present political climate is clearly not favourable to a legal line of attack from 'pro- life' groups on this point, but the avenue remains open for the future. Moreover, the way the long title of the Bill is drafted means that the Statutory Licensing Authority (SLA) established under it will have monitoring and overseeing of abortion law and developments in the scientific field included in its remit. This will increase the vulnerability of abortion rights to further medical advances in the care of premature babies.

Jo Richardson's "equal opportunities' amendment, which would have enabled the SLA not to grant or to revoke the licence of a clinic that discriminated in its provision of donor insemination (DI) and new reproductive technologies (NRTs), was defeated in Com-

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 25, June 1990

Page 21

← Namibia: a 'model' of democracy for Africa? · Equal pay for women – but not at men's expense →

Something wrong on this page?